Federal Fines, One-Star Ratings Spike, as Closures Affect Access for In-State Nursing Home Residents
Why it matters: More federal fines and one-star ratings show enforcement is getting tougher, so survey preparation and the DON's role in it matter more.
Read at Skilled Nursing News (opens publisher site)Minnesota's one-star surge points to staffing churn more than ownership type
Skilled Nursing News reported on November 11, 2026, citing the Minnesota Star Tribune, that Minnesota has far more one-star nursing homes under the CMS Five-Star system than it had in 2019. The count has nearly doubled. Federal fines for neglectful or substandard care rose from $2.3 million to $8.2 million over the same period, which the outlet describes as a tripling. The state's nursing home count fell from 376 to under 340. For-profit owners now control 30% of homes and are tied to 50% of the one-star ratings. A trade coalition wants more state money and an access guarantee for residents.
Is quality still getting worse in Minnesota?
On the reported numbers, no. Star ratings have held steady since 2023, and fines and deficiencies have eased, so the decline is measured against a 2019 baseline rather than a current trend.
The headline comparison runs from 2019 to last month. That window includes the pandemic, and it ignores the plateau since 2023. A fine total is also a lagging record of past surveys, not a reading of current care. If your own state is being compared this way, check which year the comparison starts from and whether the line has been flat since.
Does for-profit ownership explain the one-star homes?
Not cleanly. For-profit operators run 30% of homes but are linked to 50% of one-star ratings, yet the Star Tribune noted they often take over homes others won't touch.
The Skilled Nursing News wording on the 50% figure is ambiguous. It could mean half of one-star homes are for-profit, or half of for-profit homes are one-star. Those are very different claims, and the original Star Tribune piece would settle it. We have not read it. Monarch Healthcare Management's CEO, Marc Halpert, says turnarounds take time. That is the operator's account, and no turnaround timeline has been offered.
What does this mean for DON staffing and retention?
Turnover is the pressure point. The Star Tribune found a group of facilities replaced at least half their nursing staff in the past year, and for-profits report lower rates of nurses and aides per resident.
A DON running a unit where half the nursing staff is new is carrying survey risk that no rating shows. Some closures were blamed on staffing or finances, and others were conversions to assisted living. The report also notes more than 2,000 licensed assisted living facilities, many with sophisticated medical capabilities. We read that as extra competition for the same nurses. The coverage does not say so directly. Our earlier note on Virginia's assisted living audit raised the same question of staffing standards in that setting.
What should I ask my operator or staffing vendor?
Ask for your own facility's turnover and nurse-to-resident figures, who calculated them, and over what period. Request a 2023 baseline alongside any pandemic-era comparison.
If an owner or consultant promises a rating turnaround, ask for dated milestones and the metric used. Star ratings lag, so also ask for leading indicators such as agency use and vacancy length for DON and ADON roles. The trade coalition's call for guaranteed access, plus state money beyond the $300 million pandemic-era aid, remains a request. Do not budget around it.
Frequently asked questions
How many nursing homes has Minnesota lost since 2019?
The count fell from 376 to under 340, per the Star Tribune as relayed by Skilled Nursing News. Some closures were attributed to staffing or finances, and others were conversions to assisted living.
Is Minnesota weak compared with other states?
Not on the Star Tribune's measure. It reports Minnesota ranks better than many states in average star rating, even after the drop from its former nonprofit-era highs.
What are the trade groups asking for?
The Long-Term Care Imperative wants a support plan guaranteeing residents access to a nursing home within a set travel time of home. It also wants more state investment.
Sources: Skilled Nursing News, reporting on the Minnesota Star Tribune's analysis. We did not review the Star Tribune original.
More stories
-
State audit urges overhaul of Virginia assisted living oversight, staffing standards
Why it matters: Virginia assisted living operators could face tougher inspections and new staffing minimums, so it's worth checking current staffing levels and survey readiness now.
-
Agency Staffing Use Declines as Long Term Care Rebuilds Its Workforce
Why it matters: Lower agency use means facilities are rebuilding permanent staff, which cuts labor costs and should make care more consistent ahead of surveys.
-
CMS Issues Proposed Rule to Streamline Health Care Regulations
Why it matters: Changes to CMS requirements could alter what surveyors cite. DONs should check which nursing home rules are being loosened or removed.
-
Lawmakers Sound Alarm on CMS’ New Risk-Based Survey
Why it matters: Congressional pushback on CMS's risk-based survey model could change how often facilities are inspected and how DONs should plan their survey readiness.