Break a DON Finalist Tie With an In-Basket, Not a Third Interview

When two DON finalists finish close, skip the third interview. Give both the same timed in-basket of your building's call-offs, plan of correction items and budget variance, then score it.

Quick Answer

When two DON finalists finish close, skip the third interview. Give both the same timed in-basket of your building's call-offs, plan of correction items and budget variance, then score it.

Score the responses on command of survey and regulatory work and on staff leadership that keeps nurses. Leave cost guesses out. No defensible SNF figure exists for a failed leadership hire. Your ADON can sit the same packet, which is where budget gaps show.

Did this answer your question?
Three things administrators believe about DON finalists. Myth or fact?
Call each one, then see how other readers called it.
1 A third interview is the fairest way to break a tie between two DON finalists.
2 A finalist who brings a 30-60-90 plan has already shown they can do the job.
3 The same in-basket can support a promotion decision, not only an outside hire.

Run structured interviews first. Before you book another round, write down the one problem your next DON must fix first, and ask each finalist how they would start on it.

An in-basket is a long-standing assessment center exercise. The candidate plays someone new to the job and works through a pile of memos, messages and reports. For a DON, that pile should hold a weekend call-off, an open plan of correction item and a budget variance. Not hypotheticals. Your building's own.

The interview rounds still matter. Our DON interview kit takes about 3 minutes and matches its questions to your facility's pressure level, so those rounds stay structured and comparable. Even a well-run interview, though, cannot show you a finalist choosing between the labor budget and a short-staffed weekend. That choice is what the in-basket puts on paper.

Two other checks sit on either side of the decision. Before you post the role, the DON flight-risk check takes about 2 minutes and scores whether your current DON is likely to leave, which tells you whether you are hiring at all. After the offer, the survey readiness check looks at the building through a nursing leadership lens, so your new DON starts with a list instead of a guess.

I will not put a dollar figure on a bad DON hire. Our review found no defensible SNF cost per leadership hire, and no national DON turnover rate exists to anchor one. What the evidence supports is narrower and more useful: a way to make the close call on the work itself, starting with why the usual tie-breakers keep failing.

When two Director of Nursing finalists finish close, do not book a third interview. Give both the same in-basket: a timed stack of your building's real call-offs, plan of correction items and budget variance, scored against the competencies the job needs. Then offer the role to the finalist whose answers hold up.

A third conversation mostly repeats the first two. Both finalists already know how to interview. An in-basket asks them to do the work instead, and each response is rated on a standard scale tied to a job-related competency, so the comparison sits on paper rather than in memory.

The work itself is the reason. Hilanie Hauk, who rose from CNA to director of nursing and later executive director, named the DON's daily tension on a Provider Magazine podcast: "As a leader, you can't just say, 'Okay, I have to follow my budget,' but, 'Oh, hold on a minute. Somebody's not really taken care of properly because we're short-staffed.'" That trade between budget and staffing is a judgment call. Interviews rarely make a candidate show it.

The same packet answers a quieter question too. If your ADON wants the chair, the budget memo is where you find out.

Questions this article answers

Why do the usual tie-breakers leave two DON finalists still tied?

Standard Director of Nursing interview questions and reference calls draw similar answers from two strong finalists. More talk rarely separates them, so a third round mostly repeats what you already heard.

Before you book anything else, work through what you already have:

  1. Put the two scorecards side by side and circle every competency where the finalists differ by more than a point.
  2. List the questions both answered well. Those questions are finished. Asking them again tells you nothing new.
  3. Write down the one problem your building will hand the new DON in month one: an open plan of correction, a weekend staffing hole, a budget line running over.
  4. Ask whether either finalist has shown you, not told you, how they would handle that problem.

If the answer to the last step is no, the tie sits in your process. It does not sit in the candidates.

Look at what a typical DON question bank asks. The Breezy HR list for Director of Nursing candidates opens with "What was your typical day like as a nurse?" and "What was your patient volume?", then moves to "What's your experience in policy-making?" and whether nursing or management skills matter more. Two finalists who reached your last round have answered these before. They will answer them well again.

References are the next reflex. In a 2023 hiring thread on r/projectmanagement, a manager with two finalists had finished 2 rounds of interviews and did not want to put anyone through a third. Checking references was the most common suggestion, raised in 3 of 7 substantive replies. One of those commenters still called the method "not foolproof." The same manager expected the final call to come down to what HR would authorize on salary, not to anything the candidates said.

Conventional wisdom says a careful reference check settles a close call. It usually confirms what you already believe. A former supervisor describes how a nurse performed in someone else's building, under someone else's administrator, with someone else's survey history. Your building is not in that answer.

Practitioner advice on tied finalists points the same way from another angle. Decide which qualities matter most to the role before you look at the people again, then rescore them against that ranked list. A tie after several rounds often means the deciding skills were never tested at all.

Combining 4 sources points to one pattern: the usual tie-breakers measure what candidates say about past work, and close finalists say it equally well.

Pay can quietly become the tiebreaker by default. If the offer is where the finalists differ, settle the number from data, not from whoever negotiates harder. Our DON salary benchmark for 2026 is built from public sources cited on the page: BLS wage data, CMS facility and staffing data, and industry surveys. Use it to set one defensible range for both finalists.

That clears pay off the table. What is left is the question no interview has answered yet: what each finalist actually does with your Monday morning.

What is an in-basket exercise, and why does it fit a DON decision?

An in-basket is a timed stack of the memos, messages and reports a new DON would find on day one. It shows survey judgment and staff leadership as actions, not answers.

The method is not new. An HR glossary from Taggd traces it to Norman O. Frederiksen and colleagues at Educational Testing Service in the 1950s. The candidate plays someone new to the job, works through a pile of items against the clock, and moves each one from the in-basket to the out-basket. Taggd gives typical time limits of 30 to 60 minutes in one passage and one to two hours in another, and it recommends several independent raters scoring against job competencies.

The federal government uses the same tool. The U.S. Office of Personnel Management lists the in-basket as a frequently used assessment center exercise that simulates administrative tasks, and it calls assessment centers particularly effective for higher-level managerial and leadership competencies. OPM also reports that assessment center scores predict occupational success well, citing a 1987 meta-analysis by Gaugler, Rosenthal, Thornton and Bentson. How well they predict depends on the purpose, the methods used and how thoroughly the assessors were trained.

That last condition matters. Name your raters before the session, and have each one score alone before anyone compares notes.

Think about a driver's license. The written test tells you someone knows the rules of the road. Nobody hands over the keys until an examiner has watched them drive. Your structured interviews were the written test. The in-basket is the road test.

A DON's week already looks like an in-basket. A weekend call-off, a surveyor's follow-up question, a budget report that came in over, a family concern and an ADON asking for a decision can all land before nine on a Monday. What separates two good finalists is which item they pick up first, what they hand off, and what they write back.

Our DON interview kit tests the 2 qualities we treat as the mark of a successful DON: command of survey and regulatory work, and staff leadership that keeps nurses. An in-basket lets you watch both under time pressure instead of hearing them described.

The second quality carries real weight. Skilled nursing RN turnover runs about 36.5% (HCS / AHCA, 2025). A DON who covers a call-off by leaning harder on the nurses who did show up feeds that number. A DON who fixes the schedule and protects those nurses works against it. The in-basket shows you which instinct each finalist has.

One adjustment is needed for a nursing home. Taggd's healthcare example uses patient records and medication orders. For a hiring exercise, swap those for operational items and keep every resident detail out of the packet. Scenario ideas are not hard to find: the staffing, survey and payment stories in our long-term care news feed show the pressures a packet should mirror.

The research section below shows how far the scores from such a packet can be trusted.

Start the tie-break with the DON interview kit. It is one of the free tools on Director of Nursing Search, alongside the promote-or-hire quiz and the survey-readiness check, and it shows which competencies your packet still has to test.

Score delegation too. A finalist who hands off too much, or too little, is telling you how the first month will go.

Can the same in-basket show whether your ADON is ready to be DON?

Yes. Give your ADON the same packet as the outside finalists. The budget and survey items show what clinical strength cannot: whether they can own labor spend and a plan of correction.

An ADON can be clinically ready and still never have owned the labor budget or led the building through a survey revisit. If the role never handed those tasks over, the gap belongs to the job, not to the nurse. The in-basket is the cheapest way I know to see that gap before the promotion instead of after it.

The Office of Personnel Management notes that assessment centers support promotion decisions as well as outside selection. The agency adds a design point worth following. Centers built for internal promotion often reflect the organization's own practices, while those for external applicants should focus on the job and its level. When your ADON sits beside outside finalists, write every item around the DON job, not around insider knowledge. Your ADON already knows which aide calls off on Saturdays. Put the facts each item needs inside the packet so an outside finalist starts level.

OPM also finds little evidence that assessment centers pin down an individual's specific strengths and weaknesses. Give your ADON the same packet, the same time limit and the same raters as the outside finalists, so nobody can call the result a favor. Use the score to decide. Then sit down with your ADON within the week and walk through each item they handled.

Here is how I would read an ADON's result against the outside finalists:

  • Strong on staffing and survey items, weak on budget: promotable, with a written budget handoff from the administrator in the first 90 days.
  • Strong on staffing, weak on survey and budget: not yet. Name the two gaps, set a date to retest, and keep the ADON on a real succession path.
  • Weak on the staffing items: the outside finalist is the safer call, whatever the tenure.

Survey work is the gap that hurts fastest. Before you finalize, the survey readiness check on Director of Nursing Search takes about 4 minutes and reviews your regulatory readiness through a nursing leadership lens. A building with open survey exposure needs a DON who has already carried a plan of correction, or an ADON with a clear person to learn it from.

If your ADON matches or beats the outside finalists, promote. Referral fees never change what the site's tools recommend, including "promote your ADON." That holds for this advice too.

Do not let a cost guess push you either way. We dropped a turnover cost calculator from the site. The $60,090 cost to replace one bedside RN (NSI 2026) is a hospital figure, and our review found no defensible SNF cost per leadership hire. Anyone quoting you an exact price for a failed DON promotion is guessing.

What the packet does give you is specific. A low budget score next to strong staffing scores is not a no. It is the list of what the administrator hands over first, in writing, starting the week the ADON moves into the office.

How far can you trust an in-basket score when two DON finalists are tied?

Ask hiring managers how to settle a tie between two finalists and the answers run from reference calls to hiring both to a coin flip. Nobody we read suggested watching them work.

Both threads we read come from Reddit forums for managers. Neither is about nursing, but each shows the usual reflex. In a 2023 r/projectmanagement thread, a manager with two "great" finalists had already finished two rounds and wrote, "I don't want to put anyone thru a 3rd round." Reference checks were the most common suggestion, made in 3 of 7 substantive replies. In a 2026 r/managers thread about two "equally skilled" finalists, three of 13 top-level comments said to hire both, and another said there was "No wrong answer here."

Standard DON question banks work the same way. One published by Breezy HR asks "What was your typical day like as a nurse?" and "What's your experience in policy-making?" Both questions ask the candidate to tell you something. Neither asks them to do anything.

Tie-breakerWhat it lets you observeWho judgesWhat our sources say
Reference callA former colleague's account of the finalistWhoever makes the callThe most common tie-breaker in one 2023 thread, and "not foolproof" according to one commenter who recommended it
Team-fit discussionHow current staff react to each finalistThe existing teamForum advice splits between hiring for fit and choosing the "non obvious" candidate
Third unstructured interviewMore of the candidate's own description of their workThe interviewersOne manager refused to run one, and DON question banks mostly ask candidates to describe past work
Scored in-basketHow the finalist handles the memos, messages and reports a new DON would faceSeveral trained assessors using set scalesOPM says assessment center scores predict job success well, and that validity depends on assessor training

The strongest case for a work sample comes from the U.S. Office of Personnel Management, the federal government's HR agency, which publishes guidance on assessment methods. OPM calls the in-basket a frequently used exercise in assessment centers, which combine several exercises and are "particularly effective for assessing higher-level managerial and leadership competencies." Assessment center scores "do a good job predicting occupational success," OPM says, and applicants often see the process as "very fair." Two caveats apply. The validity claim covers assessment centers as a whole, and the in-basket is only one part of them. Predictive power also varies with "the extent of assessor training" and the methods used.

"So while assessment centers are highly useful for making selection decisions, they are less useful for providing comprehensive developmental feedback"

U.S. Office of Personnel Management, assessment center guidance

OPM explains why: there is little evidence that assessment centers identify an individual's relative strengths and weaknesses. A weak ADON answer on the labor budget item shows how they handled that one item on that day, and nothing more. Hilanie Hauk, a former director of nursing who now runs a long-term care community, described the tension inside such an item on a Provider Magazine podcast in October 2026: "As a leader, you can't just say, 'Okay, I have to follow my budget,' but, 'Oh, hold on a minute. Somebody's not really taken care of properly because we're short-staffed.'" A candidate who protects staffing over the budget line may be reasoning the way an experienced leader would. Standard in-basket guidance ends with a debrief where candidates explain their decisions, and that conversation matters as much as the number.

The second limit is about whose files the packet comes from. OPM advises that exercises for external applicants focus on the job and its level, and avoid practices unique to one organization. A packet built from your building's real call-offs and open plan of correction favors the ADON, who may have handled those exact items. OPM also warns that scenarios are "remembered by the applicants long after the administration," so once a packet has been used, people have seen it.

The last limit is the scoring. An HR glossary from the services company Taggd calls for rating scales tied to job competencies, with several independent raters producing the final ratings, and scales that penalize in both directions: "Candidates lose points if they delegate too much or too little." OPM says assessors must be highly trained. A new graduate in a 2026 r/StudentNurse thread described an emergency department panel where all eight interviewers read from the same question list until one asked, "If you were an animal, what kind of animal would you be?" Seven panelists wanted to hire the candidate. The eighth vetoed them because "eagles are mean."

One account proves no pattern. Still, it shows the exact failure that fixed scales and independent raters exist to prevent: a rater who drops the shared script, and rules that let one vote override everyone else.

What gives an in-basket its edge, meaning realistic work, a scale written in advance and more than one trained rater, is missing from the usual tie-breakers. Without those three things, the exercise is another conversation with paperwork attached. Even done well, it works better as a referee than as a diagnosis. The evidence for using it to choose between finalists is strong. The evidence for using it to map what one person still needs to learn is thin.

Before you trust the scores

  1. Write the score sheet before any packet goes out, including what over-delegating and under-delegating each cost.
  2. Have two or more raters score every packet separately before they compare notes, and hold every rater to the same items.
  3. Give outside finalists the same facility background your ADON already has, remove any resident information from every item, and retire the packet when the search ends.
  4. If your ADON scores low on the budget or survey items, ask in the debrief how they weighed staffing against spend before you treat the score as a verdict on readiness.

How we checked this

Our sources were federal assessment guidance from OPM, an HR glossary on in-basket exercises, a published DON interview question bank, a 2026 podcast interview with a long-term care executive director and three Reddit threads. The Reddit threads are individual accounts, and two of them involve roles outside nursing. None of the figures in this section come from us. OPM's validity findings cover assessment centers as a whole, not in-baskets on their own, and the OPM page has no date. The glossary cites studies without naming them, and its publisher sells HR services. We earn a referral fee when we introduce an employer to a recruiting firm, as our disclosure page explains. The exercise described here is one an employer runs on its own. Still unknown: none of our sources tested an in-basket specifically for DON or skilled nursing hires.

  1. U.S. Office of Personnel Management, guidance on assessment centers, undated.
  2. Taggd, HR glossary entry on the in-basket technique, October 2025.
  3. Breezy HR, director of nursing interview questions, July 2025.
  4. Provider Magazine, podcast interview with Hilanie Hauk, October 2026.
  5. Reddit r/projectmanagement, thread on breaking a tie between two candidates, May 2023.
  6. Reddit r/managers, thread on choosing between two top candidates, July 2026.
  7. Reddit r/StudentNurse, thread on ICU and ER panel interviews, July 2026.

What should you do once the in-basket scores are in?

Offer the role to the higher scorer, then build the first 90 days from their answers. In Texas, 36.6% of nursing home DONs had held the role under a year.

That figure comes from the Texas health department for 2024, and it describes Texas only. Still, it tells you how short the runway can be. I would not let the in-basket packet go into a drawer after the offer.

Hand it back to the new DON. Ask for a written 30-60-90 plan built on the same call-offs, survey items and budget lines they just worked through. On r/PMCareers, a nurse with an MBA who was heading into a senior project manager interview prepared exactly that kind of roadmap, plus a 90-second presentation of it. One commenter said presenting such a plan was "probably the reason I got the job." Another pushed back: "Move faster. Prioritize."

Both points apply to your building. The plan shows intent. The first 30 days show whether the budget memo answer was real.

Summarize This Article With AI

Open this article in your preferred AI engine for an instant summary.

Frequently Asked Questions

What else do administrators ask about breaking a DON finalist tie?

Most follow-up questions cover references, pay, hiring both finalists and how the in-basket works. Each answer points back to scored work, not another conversation.

Should I check references to break a tie between DON finalists?

Yes, but ask a sharper question than "would you rehire them?" In a 2023 r/projectmanagement thread on tied finalists, one commenter said the reference "should state that they would take back the candidate in an instance." Hold every DON reference to that bar. Then let the in-basket settle what references cannot show.

What is an in-basket exercise?

An in-basket exercise is a timed set of memos, messages and reports a candidate handles as if new to the job. Raters score each response against job-related competencies on a standard scale. For a DON, the items come from your own building.

Can I hire both finalists?

Only if a second leadership seat is real and funded, such as an open ADON role. I would not invent a job to avoid a decision. The runner-up will notice.

Should salary decide the tie?

Pay matters, so settle the approved range with HR before final interviews, not after. Then the tie gets decided on the work. Check any pay exception with your own HR or counsel.

What does Director of Nursing Search charge for hiring help?

Hiring help starts with a free 15-minute intro call. If a search makes sense and you agree, Director of Nursing Search introduces a specialist recruiting firm that fits the role, state and timeline. The site earns a referral fee for that introduction, as the disclosure page explains. You can book the intro here.

Written by

Dorian Hammer

Editor, Director of Nursing Search

Dorian Hammer edits the guides at Director of Nursing Search, written for administrators and owners of skilled nursing facilities and assisted living communities who need to hire or keep a Director of Nursing or ADON.

View profile