Why the DON Seat Keeps Emptying: Role Stacking, Not Pay

You keep losing DONs because the job is failing, not the hires: stacking infection prevention, MDS and scheduling onto one RN seat makes it unworkable, and a raise does not change that.

Quick Answer

You keep losing DONs because the job is failing, not the hires: stacking infection prevention, MDS and scheduling onto one RN seat makes it unworkable, and a raise does not change that.

Fix the seat before you refill it. Give each stacked duty a named owner and make the ADON a real deputy. An interim DON covers the gap but leaves the job as it was. Public data on DON tenure is thin, so pull your own exit dates this week.

Did this answer your question?
Three things administrators believe about DON turnover. Myth or fact?
Call each one, then see how other readers called it.
1 A nurse leader can call the pay good and still plan to step down.
2 Rules already treat nursing leadership as a separate job from running the building.
3 A bigger raise will keep a DON whose duties keep growing.

An interim DON buys coverage, but it only pays off if the weeks it buys go to pulling scheduling, MDS and infection prevention off the seat before the next hire.

I will be plain about the limit here. None of the public sources behind this article prices an open DON seat against an interim contract, so I will not put a dollar figure on either side. What the sources do show is where the work goes when the chair is empty.

Start with the rules. A federal HHS summary of one state's assisted living requirements lists a facility director with overall responsibility for meeting statutory and regulatory requirements, and a separate nursing leader: "Every ALF must have a director of nursing who is an RN." Two jobs. Two people.

Leave the DON seat open and that RN requirement does not go away. Someone covers nursing leadership, and in a building that stacked duties on the last DON, the person covering inherits the schedule, the MDS calendar and infection control along with it. That is how one vacancy can turn into two.

An interim DON fixes coverage. It does not fix the job.

So the real question for your building is not interim versus open. It is what the seat will look like on the day a permanent DON walks in. If the answer is the same stacked job, the interim is only buying time for the next exit. Before you sign anything, write down which duties the interim will not carry, and the name of the person who will.

If your building has lost two Directors of Nursing in a row, do not post the same job a third time. Ask what the seat carries besides nursing leadership. Infection prevention, MDS, scheduling and hiring have been stacked onto one RN seat, and each new DON walks into the same overload on day one.

The public data on how fast the seat empties is thin. In our October 2026 review of public sources, we found only one figure on DON tenure, and it covers Texas only: 36.6% of Texas nursing home DONs had held the role under a year (TX DSHS, 2024). We found no published national DON or ADON turnover rate. Nobody can quote you national odds. Ask one question at your next leadership meeting: which of the last DON's duties did nobody else know how to cover?

The rules give you a baseline to read against. The HHS planning office summary of state assisted living rules treats the facility director, who answers for regulatory compliance, and the RN director of nursing as two separate required positions. Stack enough duties onto the DON and that line disappears.

Pull your last two DON job posts and count the duties that are not nursing leadership. Every one of those duties needs a second name before the next offer goes out.

Questions this article answers

Ready to rebuild the DON job before you refill it?

Run the free DON flight-risk quiz and job-ad builder from Director of Nursing Search, then book a free 15-minute intro if a search still makes sense.

Fix the duty list first. If a search is the right call, we introduce a specialist recruiting firm that fits the role, state and timeline, with your agreement.

What has the Director of Nursing job turned into?

Your DON is short the RNs who would take delegated work, with skilled nursing RN turnover at about 36.5%. Every duty nobody else can hold drifts onto one desk.

HCS and AHCA reported that RN turnover rate for 2025. When staff nurses churn at that pace, the DON stops leading nurses and starts covering for them. Before you post the job again, list what your DON actually did last week. Mark each item that sits on that desk:

  • Staff scheduling and call-off coverage, including the early morning phone calls.
  • Hiring and onboarding new nurses and aides.
  • MDS assessments and coordination.
  • Infection prevention program work and surveillance.
  • Administrative tasks that belong to the administrator.

Every mark is time taken from clinical oversight. Three or more marks and you are not hiring a DON. You are hiring a department.

A 2026 research release from a senior living finance firm claims that DONs devote considerable time to hiring, onboarding and scheduling on top of their clinical leadership work. Read that as the firm's own claim. It still lines up with what people inside buildings say in public.

On an Indeed employee Q&A page for a New Orleans nursing home, a question posted in 2018 asked why the building could not keep DONs or floor nurses. A former business office manager answered in 2025 with four words: "Overworked and always short-staffed." An earlier respondent said the administrator "acts more like the DON." Neither answer mentioned pay. One describes a workload problem. The other describes a role with blurred edges, where the DON's authority leaks upward and the DON's chores pile up.

An allnurses thread from 2006 put it more bluntly. "There is a reason that DON's come and go," one long-term care nurse wrote, adding that the nurse may not be suited to the job, but the job may also be overwhelming and carry high liability. In the same thread, a nurse stepping into the director of nursing services role listed the posts held first. PPS/MDS coordinator was its own line on that list. In that building, MDS was a separate job.

An analysis of 4 sources shows the same pattern: short-staffed nurses, a DON pulled into hiring and scheduling, duties that once had their own owner, and exits that nobody ties to salary. The common assumption is that a DON who leaves early could not handle the job. If you held exit interviews, reread them for one thing: the duty that ate the most hours and was not nursing leadership.

That changes where you look first. Write each duty on the current job description next to the name of whoever did it last month, and circle every line where that name is the DON's.

Pay still matters, and you should know where your offer sits against the DON salary benchmark for your state. The harder question is whether a bigger number buys any time when the stacked duties stay put.

Is it the pay, or the job, that keeps emptying the DON seat?

When a Director of Nursing quits, people usually suspect the paycheck first. Nurse leaders who have walked away and new research on the role keep pointing somewhere else.

In 2006, a nursing student in Nashville posted on allnurses that whenever they opened The Tennessean, "it seems that two or three nursing homes are looking for a DON." A long-term care nurse replied with a warning: "There is a reason that DON's come and go." The reason, the nurse added, might be the nurse, or a job too overwhelming and too high in liability.

Twenty years later, hard data is still scarce. Our October 2026 review of public sources found one figure on DON tenure, and it covers one state.

36.6%

Share of Texas nursing home DONs who had held the role for under a year, Texas Department of State Health Services, 2024. We found no published national turnover rate for DONs or ADONs.

An administrator refilling the seat a third time may be part of a common pattern, but no national number can show it. To learn why the seat empties, you have to look at what the job contains.

Ziegler's 2026 research on DONs in senior living gives the clearest look so far. Its release describes DONs "devoting considerable time to hiring, onboarding, and scheduling alongside their clinical leadership responsibilities."

Call recruitment and retention a significant challenge More than 70%
Feel overwhelmed, stretched too thin or work past scheduled hours, often or almost always More than 60%
Spend more than 60% of the workweek on administrative and non-clinical work 46%
Where DON time and energy go. Share of DON respondents, from Ziegler's 2026 research on directors of nursing in senior living, as reported in its press release.

Ziegler's own recommendations read like a description of the problem: "protecting time for clinical responsibilities" and "addressing burnout before it contributes to turnover."

Personal accounts sound much the same. In July 2026, a Texas nurse who directs a 12-person intake and admissions department, and says plainly the role is not a DON job, asked on Reddit whether to step down. "Salary is good ($92k in Texas), but working M-F, plus all the calls when I'm off work." Commenters fixated on pay until the poster added an edit, because "everyone seems to be mentioning the salary." On an Indeed page about a New Orleans nursing home, someone asked why it could not keep DONs. A former business office manager answered in 2025: "Overworked and always short-staffed." An anonymous answer from 2018 said "The Administrator acts more like the DON." These are single, unverified accounts. They show how people describe leaving but cannot show how often each reason applies.

Pay still matters at the margins. That Texas director earns roughly $44 an hour, while staff nurses in the department earn about $38. A commenter new to a coordinator role put the gap at about $5k a year and now works through lunch and before and after every shift. With a premium that thin, an always-on job loses easily to a bedside shift that ends on time.

Some of the stacking is allowed by the rules, especially in small buildings.

DutyWhat the rule or research saysQuestion for your building
Charge nurse shiftsA DON may serve as charge nurse only when average daily occupancy is 60 or fewer residents (42 CFR 483.35)Are we under that line, and is the DON our backup coverage?
Infection preventionA designated, specially trained infection preventionist who works at least part-time at the facility. The rule text does not say who that must be (42 CFR 483.80)Is the IP a named person other than the DON?
Hiring, onboarding, schedulingDONs devote "considerable time" to them alongside clinical leadership (Ziegler, 2026)Who owns the schedule when a shift falls apart?
Small assisted livingDelaware allows a part-time DON at 5 to 24 licensed beds, and assisted living rules there list the facility director and the RN DON as separate positionsIs a part-time DON also covering other jobs?

Side by side, the findings line up. Where tenure has been measured, the seat turns over fast. Most DONs surveyed report overload. People walking away talk about calls on days off and short staffing. And the rules leave room to hand one RN several jobs. No published dataset links particular stacked duties to particular resignations, so this is a consistent pattern rather than proof. Still, a new job posting only changes who sits in the seat. The job stays the same until someone redesigns it.

  • Track your own DON tenure. With no national rate published, your building's history is the benchmark you control, with the Texas figure as a reference point.
  • Before you repost, list every duty your last DON actually carried and estimate the share of the week spent on administrative and non-clinical work, the yardstick Ziegler uses to measure the strain.
  • In exit and stay interviews, ask about calls on days off and hours past the schedule as well as salary. The people leaving tend to bring up the first two.
  • Check your average daily occupancy against the federal 60-resident line, and confirm in writing who your infection preventionist is. If either answer is "the DON," decide whether that was a plan or an accident.
  • If you benchmark pay, compare the DON premium with what your own staff nurses earn per hour. When the gap is thin, ask what would make the seat worth keeping.

How we checked this

Sources: federal regulations, a Delaware rule, a federal summary of state rules, an industry research release, and three online forums. The tenure figure is a Texas state number, and our October 2026 review of public sources (our own work) is the basis for saying no national DON or ADON rate exists. We read Ziegler's press release, not the full report, so we could not see its sample size or method, and its respondents work in senior living. The Reddit, Indeed and allnurses posts are individual and unverified, and Indeed notes that it does not guarantee the accuracy of its content. The Reddit poster is a department director, not a DON. Still unknown: whether moving specific duties off the DON's desk measurably lengthens tenure. None of our sources tested that.

  1. Texas Department of State Health Services, nursing home DON tenure figure, 2024, as found in our October 2026 review of public sources.
  2. Ziegler, press release on 2026 DON research, 2026.
  3. eCFR, 42 CFR 483.35 nursing services rule, retrieved November 18, 2026.
  4. eCFR, 42 CFR 483.80 infection control rule, retrieved November 18, 2026.
  5. State of Delaware, 3225 Assisted Living Facilities regulation, undated.
  6. ASPE, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, summary of Delaware assisted living rules, undated.
  7. Reddit r/nursing, thread on quitting a director job, July 22, 2026.
  8. Indeed, employee Q&A on DON turnover at a New Orleans nursing home, answers from 2018 and 2025.
  9. allnurses, thread on whether a DON job is realistic, September 8, 2006.

What should a nursing home pay a Director of Nursing in Texas, and will a raise hold the seat?

Pay to the market, using a benchmark built from public BLS, CMS and industry survey data. Then fix the job, because no raise holds a seat that never goes off call.

Start with an honest caveat. The DON role has no BLS occupation category of its own, so every DON pay figure for Texas or any other state is an estimate built from nearby categories. Our DON pay benchmark is built from public sources cited on the page: BLS wage data, CMS facility and staffing data, and industry surveys. Use it to set a fair range. Do not expect it to settle why the last DON left.

Conventional wisdom says a bigger offer fixes a revolving seat. A July 2026 thread on Reddit's r/nursing forum tests that idea. The poster ran an intake and admissions department in Texas with 12 full-time employees. That is not a DON seat, and the poster said so. The salary was $92k, about $44/hr, against about $38/hr for the department's staff nurses, a gap of roughly $6/hr.

The poster called the salary good. The complaint was the schedule: Monday to Friday, "plus all the calls when I'm off work." Housework, errands and projects had gone. "Work stress always comes home with me," the poster wrote. When commenters kept pointing at the pay, the poster added an edit to steer them back to the hours. A commenter newly in an interim coordinator role told a similar story. The pay gap over bedside was about $5k, and the job now meant working through lunch plus about 20 minutes before and 30 minutes after each shift.

Read those two accounts side by side. The money was not the complaint. The reach of the job into every day off was.

A raise changes the number on the offer letter. It does not change who answers the phone on a Saturday night. If your DON still owns scheduling and call-offs, the raise buys a few months at most, and then you are back on the job boards.

So use pay as a tool for the role you redesign, not as a patch over the role you have. Our hire-and-retain pay plan takes about 5 minutes and builds a DON starting salary plus tranche-style raises tied to milestones at 3, 6 and 12 months. Tie each tranche to something that changes on the floor, such as a stable schedule owner or a clean infection control round. That plan is general guidance, not legal, HR or financial advice, so check it with your own counsel before it goes into an offer.

Pay will keep moving with the market. The bigger question is what the job itself is supposed to be, and the regulators have already answered part of it.

How can I tell if my Director of Nursing is a flight risk, and how do I make the job survivable?

Watch the duties, not the mood. A DON covering scheduling, MDS and infection prevention is at risk long before a resignation letter, and moving those duties is the fix.

Start with what the rules describe. The HHS planning office (ASPE) summary of state assisted living rules requires every facility to have a director with overall responsibility for meeting statutory and regulatory requirements, and a separate director of nursing who is an RN. Two seats. Two jobs. Delaware's assisted living regulation 3225 goes further and scales DON time to the size of the building: facilities licensed for 25 or more assisted living beds must have a full-time DON, and facilities with 5 through 24 beds must have a part-time DON.

Notice what those rules size the job by. Beds and residents. Not the number of extra hats. When your building adds infection prevention, MDS and the schedule to the DON, you are quietly shrinking the nursing leadership time the rule pictured. Rules differ by state and by license type, so check yours with counsel before you restructure.

I would sort your warning signs into two columns before you decide anything about the person in the chair.

What you seePoints to the personPoints to the job
Missed MDS deadlinesOnly this DON, in a building where MDS has its own coordinatorEvery recent DON, because MDS sits on the DON's desk
Infection control findingsProgram exists, DON ignores itNo separate infection preventionist, DON runs it alone
DON answering call-offs on days offDON will not delegate to a capable schedulerThere is no scheduler to delegate to
Same exit reason from two DONs in a rowRareAlmost always

None of the public sources cited here counts how many DONs carry these extra duties. Your own duty log is the number that matters. Then act on it this week:

  1. Name one owner for the schedule who is not the DON.
  2. Decide whether MDS and infection prevention get their own role or a shared one across buildings.
  3. Write the ADON into the plan as the DON's deputy, with named duties, so the building is never one resignation from an empty seat.
  4. Run the DON flight-risk quiz on your current DON before you touch the job ad.

The ADON step does double duty. A deputy who already holds part of the load is your succession plan and your delegation plan at once. Our promote-or-hire quiz will tell you to promote your ADON, or to keep the DON you have, when that is the honest answer.

Take one question into your next one-on-one with your DON: which task would you hand off tomorrow if someone else could own it? The answer tells you where the job breaks, and where the next posting has to start.

What should you do before you post the DON job again?

Redesign the seat before you refill it. Move scheduling, MDS and infection prevention to named owners, then hire a DON into a job one RN can actually hold.

This is not a new problem. Back in 2006, a nursing student on allnurses noticed that "two or three nursing homes" seemed to be advertising for a DON every time they opened the Nashville paper. The ads kept running because the jobs kept emptying.

My read is that the next couple of years will split operators into two groups. One keeps raising the offer and reposting the same stacked job. The other pulls the extra duties off the seat and keeps its DON. Draft the new post with the free DON job-ad builder on Director of Nursing Search, which needs no sign-up to see results, and list only the duties the DON will keep. Then ask each finalist which of the removed duties they would want back, and why.

Pull your DON exit dates this week. If two DONs left for the same reason, you already know which group you are in.

Summarize This Article With AI

Open this article in your preferred AI engine for an instant summary.

Frequently Asked Questions

What else do administrators ask about DON turnover and role stacking?

Most questions come back to one decision: fix the job or refill it. These answers cover pay, shared duties, small buildings and what our help costs.

Is repeat DON turnover a pay problem or a job design problem?

When the same seat keeps emptying, look at the job first. In a 2026 r/nursing thread, a Texas nurse director called the salary good and still weighed going back to staff nursing. The complaint was calls on days off, not the paycheck.

Should my DON also be the infection preventionist or MDS coordinator?

Not in a building that keeps losing DONs. Role stacking means loading infection prevention, MDS or scheduling duties onto the DON seat, and each one is a workload of its own. Give each duty a named owner.

Can a small assisted living community use a part-time DON?

Sometimes. At least one state ties full-time or part-time DON requirements to licensed bed count. Check your own state's rules before you cut hours.

Will a retention pay plan keep a new DON?

It helps once the job is survivable. Milestone raises reward the hard first year, but they cannot fix a seat carrying three jobs. Treat any pay plan as general guidance and check it with your counsel before you use it.

What does Director of Nursing Search cost, and how does the hiring help work?

Hiring help starts with a free 15-minute intro. If a search makes sense and you agree, we introduce a specialist recruiting firm that fits the role, state and timeline. The site is free, and it earns a referral fee when it introduces an employer to a specialist recruiting firm (see our disclosure). Employers never pay us, and candidates never pay anything. Most searches are direct hire, so your DON joins your payroll. You can book the intro here.

Written by

Dorian Hammer

Editor, Director of Nursing Search

Dorian Hammer edits the guides at Director of Nursing Search, written for administrators and owners of skilled nursing facilities and assisted living communities who need to hire or keep a Director of Nursing or ADON.

View profile