Industry news Medicare payment

‘Byzantine Ownership Arrangements’: Calls to Scrutinize Coding and Profit Incentives in Nursing Home Medicare Payments

Skilled Nursing News, . Our note:

Why it matters: Pressure to audit PDPM coding and related-party profits means MDS accuracy, which DONs oversee, could face sharper federal scrutiny.

Read at Skilled Nursing News (opens publisher site)

MedPAC's SNF payment review is a long game: expect scrutiny of coding, ownership and admissions, but no answers until 2027

Skilled Nursing News reported that the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPAC), the nonpartisan body that advises Congress on Medicare, discussed a research work plan at its October meeting on Friday. The plan assesses payment accuracy in fee-for-service Medicare's skilled nursing and home health payment systems. It covers coding distortions, payment inaccuracies, and whether financial incentives shape which patients providers accept. The analyses span 2021–2025, with initial results expected in fall 2027. Commissioner Scott Sarran, a chief medical officer at Harmonic Health, described "Byzantine ownership arrangements" with private equity somewhere in the mix. Commissioner Kenny Kan worried that providers are using AI to inflate reported patient complexity.

What will MedPAC actually examine?

MedPAC staff will examine trends in coding, case mix, payment-to-cost relationships and patient selection across 2021–2025, checking whether they look consistent with payment incentives in skilled nursing and home health.

The researchers will also weigh facility specialization, ownership and workforce pressures. Workforce is the item our readers should notice. If your staffing picture is thin or unstable, you will have less to point to when an outlier pattern needs explaining.

Is this an accusation of upcoding?

No. The work plan has produced no findings, and a MedPAC researcher said the analysis is meant to spot trends rather than prove that payment reforms caused changes in coding or provider behavior.

The strong language came from commissioners, not from analysis. Sarran spoke from decades on the provider and payer sides. The reported remarks gave no ownership figures, so "increasingly for profit" is an impression, not a measured result. He also allowed that care responding to incentives is not necessarily bad. He pointed out that medical advances are raising demand for rehabilitation and post-acute care, and he asked researchers to look at barriers to access.

This site has covered shareholder litigation involving The Ensign Group. That is investor-side pressure on a listed operator. MedPAC's work is a separate, policy-side line of scrutiny, and nothing in the reported remarks names any operator.

Why should a Director of Nursing care about a payment study?

Because coding and case-mix trends are drawn from claims and assessment data that facilities already file, and documentation quality shapes how a facility's numbers read when someone finally looks at them.

Kan urged researchers to find accuracy improvements using existing claims and assessment data instead of adding documentation, reporting or compliance burdens. That is good news for paperwork in the short term. It also means the data you have already submitted will speak for you, with no chance to add context later. The coverage did not make this point: your records are the evidence base.

Admissions are in scope too. Researchers said interviews had raised concerns about SNFs being reluctant to admit certain high-cost patients, and Sarran suggested interviewing hospital discharge planners. If your clinical team screens referrals, keep a clear record of why a referral was declined.

What should I ask my software vendors?

Ask any vendor touching documentation or coding whether its software suggests or optimizes assessment entries, who validated that logic, and whether you can produce an audit trail showing clinician intent.

Kan's AI concern was aimed at health systems and providers generally, not nursing homes specifically. But any tool marketed on revenue uplift deserves the same questions. Who defined "accuracy" or "uplift"? Who measured it, and against what baseline? Sarran also proposed separating fee-for-service from Medicare Advantage results. Ask whether your vendor's reporting can do the same, because a blended number can hide a different incentive in each payer type.

Frequently asked questions

When will results arrive?

Initial results are expected in fall 2027. The analysis covers 2021–2025, so it will be looking back at your recent history.

Does MedPAC set payment rates or audit facilities?

No. It is an advisory body that analyzes Medicare payment policy and recommends changes to Congress and the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.

Does the review include Medicare Advantage?

The stated scope is fee-for-service Medicare. Sarran suggested analyzing fee-for-service and Medicare Advantage separately, but the coverage does not say whether that was adopted.

Sources: Skilled Nursing News, reporting by Zahida Siddiqi on the MedPAC October meeting.

More stories