Nursing Home Fines Fall Across 49 States Despite More Deficiencies, Report Finds
Why it matters: Surveyors are citing more deficiencies even as fines drop in 49 states, so survey readiness still matters even when penalties are lighter.
Read at Skilled Nursing News (opens publisher site)Lower nursing home fines are not a sign that survey risk is easing
Skilled Nursing News reported in October 2026 on a new report from the Long Term Care Community Coalition (LTCCC), a New York-based nonprofit. LTCCC analysed deficiencies and fines per resident rather than per facility. It found that 94% of deficiencies cited nationwide from 2022 to 2024 were classified below actual harm. Deficiencies rose in 2024 against 2022, yet fines fell 56.5%, and 49 states imposed fewer fines in 2024. Average fines per resident dropped from $186 in 2022 to $153 in 2024. Illinois was highest at $465 per resident and Arizona lowest at $35.
Does a drop in fines mean survey risk is falling for my building?
No. Deficiencies increased over the same period, so surveyors are still finding problems. The money attached to those findings fell, which says little about how often you will be cited.
The two trends moving in opposite directions is the point. A facility can expect citations to keep coming while penalties soften. Your survey-readiness work should track the deficiency count, not the fine total. Fines are a lagging and politically variable output. Citations are what land on your public record and what your plan of correction has to answer.
How much does my state change my exposure?
Considerably. LTCCC found wide differences between states in how many deficiencies were cited and how severely, across infection control, staffing, pressure ulcers, antipsychotic drugs and residents' rights.
The infection-control figures show the spread. Tennessee classified 11.3% of its infection-control deficiencies as harm or immediate jeopardy. Alabama, Alaska, Maryland, Nevada and the District of Columbia cited none at those levels over the whole period. Many states also recorded no harm citations for understaffing in 2024, and several recorded none for antipsychotic deficiencies across the study years.
Identical practice can be scored differently depending on who walks in. If you operate in more than one state, do not assume one corporate standard predicts outcomes everywhere. Equally, a quiet citation history in your state may reflect surveyor habit rather than your clinical quality.
Whose numbers are these, and how far should I trust them?
The analysis is LTCCC's, an advocacy group that describes a "persistent accountability gap". It chose the per-resident framing and the five clinical categories. Treat the direction as credible and the interpretation as advocacy.
Skilled Nursing News gives no explanation for why fines fell, and neither do we. The coverage does not say whether the cause is fewer penalties imposed, smaller amounts, or a change in how enforcement is applied. Per-resident averaging also hides facility-level outliers, so one large penalty can move a state's figure. The 94% share below actual harm is a classification outcome. It reflects how surveyors scored severity, not a direct measure of care quality. A buyer should read these as comparisons of enforcement behaviour, not facility performance.
What should I ask my own team and vendors?
Ask for your deficiency trend by category, separate from penalties, and for how your state's severity scoring compares with neighbouring states. Ask consultants whether their mock-survey scoring is calibrated to your state.
The LTCCC call for "more consistent and more resident-centered oversight" is a signal worth planning around. If enforcement tightens, the categories with the largest state-to-state gaps are infection control, staffing, pressure ulcers, antipsychotics and residents' rights. Those are the places where harsher scoring would hurt first. A readiness vendor that quotes you an "average fine avoided" should be asked who measured it and over which states.
Frequently asked questions
Did fines fall everywhere?
Nearly everywhere. The report says 49 states imposed fewer fines in 2024 than in 2022, though the size of the change and the starting points differ widely.
Does a lower fine total help my budget planning?
Only marginally. Fines are unpredictable and state-dependent. Staffing, training and documentation costs tied to preventing citations are the more reliable line items.
Is a deficiency below actual harm still a problem?
Yes. It is still a citation requiring a correction plan, and the report shows most citations sit at that level. Repeat findings in one area invite closer attention.
Sources: Skilled Nursing News, reporting on the Long Term Care Community Coalition report.
More stories
-
Federal Fines, One-Star Ratings Spike, as Closures Affect Access for In-State Nursing Home Residents
Why it matters: More federal fines and one-star ratings show enforcement is getting tougher, so survey preparation and the DON's role in it matter more.
-
State audit urges overhaul of Virginia assisted living oversight, staffing standards
Why it matters: Virginia assisted living operators could face tougher inspections and new staffing minimums, so it's worth checking current staffing levels and survey readiness now.
-
Agency Staffing Use Declines as Long Term Care Rebuilds Its Workforce
Why it matters: Lower agency use means facilities are rebuilding permanent staff, which cuts labor costs and should make care more consistent ahead of surveys.
-
CMS Issues Proposed Rule to Streamline Health Care Regulations
Why it matters: Changes to CMS requirements could alter what surveyors cite. DONs should check which nursing home rules are being loosened or removed.