5 Contract Terms to Check Before Signing a DON Recruiting Firm

To vet a DON recruiting firm, read five terms before you sign: exclusivity length, the candidate ownership window, the fee base, replacement clause exclusions, and conflict rules for competing local clients.

Quick Answer

To vet a DON recruiting firm, read five terms before you sign: exclusivity length, the candidate ownership window, the fee base, replacement clause exclusions, and conflict rules for competing local clients.

Each one shows whether the firm shares the risk of a failed hire or shifts it onto your building. Read the replacement clause first. A promise to try is not a promise to replace, and the exclusions decide which departures count.

Did this answer your question?
Three things administrators believe about DON recruiter contracts. Myth or fact?
Call each one, then see how other readers called it.
1 No published figure shows what it costs a skilled nursing facility to replace its DON.
2 The fee rate is the term that decides how much risk your building carries.
3 Once you sign, a firm cannot recruit for the nursing home across town.

A DON search agreement is a risk contract written as a service agreement. Ask each firm for its standard agreement before the first call, and read it with your own counsel before any candidate names change hands.

Regulators have started writing that split down for staffing agencies. A state measure summarized by the law firm Koley Jessen bars agencies from negotiating certain terms of employment with nurses and CNAs, raises penalties for violations, and adds new required provisions to contracts between agencies and health care facilities. A direct-hire DON search is not shift staffing, and a rule written for agencies may not reach your search firm. Ask your counsel whether it does. The direction is still plain. Some lawmakers now treat the facility contract as the place to settle who bears what.

I wrote this guide for the person who signs: the administrator, executive director or owner of a skilled nursing facility (SNF) or assisted living community. It walks through the replacement clause and what its exclusions actually cover, what the fee is calculated on, how long exclusivity and candidate ownership last, and what to ask a firm that also recruits for the building across town. A side-by-side scorecard follows, so you can mark up two proposals on one page.

It does not fit every building. If your ADON is ready to step up, the right first move may be no search at all.

Start with the clause most contracts bury near the back.

Before you sign a DON search agreement, read five terms: how long exclusivity runs, how long the firm owns a candidate it sent you, what the fee is calculated on, what the replacement clause excludes, and whether the firm also recruits for the building down the road. Together, those five terms show whether a recruiting firm shares the risk of a failed hire or hands it to your building.

Most administrators read the rate first. I read it last. The rate tells you what a good outcome costs. The other terms decide who pays when the new DON leaves early, fails a check, or takes a call from a competitor's recruiter.

Do two things before any contract reaches your desk. Our DON flight-risk check takes about 2 minutes and scores whether your current DON is likely to leave. Our survey readiness check takes about 4 minutes and reviews regulatory readiness through a nursing leadership lens. If neither points to an urgent search, you have room to negotiate.

State rules shape the deal as well. Florida's nursing services rule says a DON or ADON "must serve only one nursing home facility in this capacity, and shall not serve as the administrator of the nursing home facility." Any shared or split leadership arrangement a firm proposes has to fit inside a rule like that, so ask how it does before you read the term sheet.

Questions this article answers

Why should you read the replacement clause before any other term?

In Texas, 36.6% of nursing home DONs had held the role under a year in 2024, so the replacement clause is the term your building is most likely to test.

Read the clause in this order, with a pen:

  1. Find the verb. Does the firm say it must replace, or only that it will endeavor to?
  2. Find the trigger. Does a resignation count, or only a termination for cause?
  3. Find the qualifiers. Words like "if necessary" or "timely" with no definition leave room to argue.
  4. Find the window. How many months after the start date does the promise last?

The tenure figure comes from the Texas Department of State Health Services. It covers Texas only. It is not a national rate, and it does not say those DONs left the building. What it does show is a leadership seat that turns over often enough that you should expect to use whatever protection you buy. The floor under your DON is moving too: skilled nursing RN turnover runs about 36.5% (HCS / AHCA, 2025), so a new DON often inherits a nursing team that is also changing.

Public contracts show how far apart the wording can be. Solano County's agreement with Amergis Healthcare Staffing says Amergis "will endeavor to provide a qualified replacement" for cancelled placements. Endeavor is a promise to try. It is not a promise to deliver.

Now compare a managed care contract published by Texas Health and Human Services: "The MCO must ensure project continuity by timely replacement of Key Personnel, if necessary, with a sufficient number of persons having the requisite skills, experience, and other qualifications." Must is an obligation. Even so, that excerpt leaves "if necessary" and "timely" undefined, which is exactly where a dispute over when replacement is owed, and how fast, would start.

The common assumption is that a contract with a replacement section protects you. The heading does not decide that. Ask the firm which terms in its standard agreement it has changed for other buildings, and start your markup there. Before the first call, highlight every condition in the clause and ask the firm, in writing, which DON exits it would still replace and by what date.

One caveat. The public record does not show how often search firms honor these clauses, or how quickly they produce a second slate. The wording on the page is the only evidence you will have on the day your DON resigns, so it has to carry the weight.

In practice, ask for three things in writing: a must, a defined trigger that includes resignation, and a deadline for presenting new candidates. A replacement search also reopens the pay conversation, so keep the DON salary benchmark for your state open when you set those terms, because a second search priced off a stale offer tends to stall at the same point the first one did.

Which promises in a recruiting contract hold up when a DON hire fails?

A replacement clause reads like insurance. We read the exact wording in public healthcare staffing contracts, and several promises turned out narrower than their headings suggested.

A caveat first: none of the three contracts we read is a DON search agreement. Two are county staffing agreements and one is a Texas managed care contract, public because government bodies post them. They show how replacement and fee language gets drafted, and cannot tell you what a particular search firm will offer.

Start with replacement. A staffing agreement on Solano County's public records system, signed with a national healthcare staffing firm, says the firm "will endeavor to provide a qualified replacement" for cancelled placements. A Merced County agreement asks its agency for "commercially reasonable efforts" once a placed worker fails a background check. The firmest of the three, a Texas Health and Human Services contract, requires "timely replacement of Key Personnel, if necessary." The passage we read does not define timely, and it does not say who decides what is necessary.

ContractThe wordingWhat the vendor commits toWhat the buyer must do
Solano County staffing agreement"will endeavor to provide a qualified replacement"An attempt to replace a cancelled placementNot stated in the excerpt we read
Merced County staffing agreement"commercially reasonable efforts"Reasonable effort after a failed background check. The rest of the sentence is cut off in the public copyNotify the agency within twenty-four (24) hours
Texas HHS managed care contract"timely replacement of Key Personnel, if necessary"Replacement, with no deadline definedNot stated in the excerpt we read

In the text we could read, each clause commits the vendor to trying, and none sets a deadline or a guaranteed result. Suppose a new DON leaves early. An effort clause leaves two questions open: when the next candidate arrives, and on what terms.

The buyer's obligations are written differently. Under the Merced agreement, the county owes "no obligation to pay any Agency fees" for staff who fail the background check. That protection is real. It also comes with a deadline that falls on the client: "Client shall provide notice to Agency within twenty-four (24) hours." Miss the notice and the waiver may be at risk. The vendor's side is written as effort, while the buyer's side is a stopwatch.

Getting out of a contract can be just as conditional. Iain Stauffer and Christopher Dwight, attorneys at Poyner Spruill who advise long term care providers, wrote in Provider magazine that a long contract "locks in the center, and it could be forced to remain with a poorly performing vendor." They add that termination for cause and termination without cause often carry separate notice periods: "Never assume that notice periods are the same." The Solano agreement runs for "one (1) year." Either side may end it early only "in accordance with the terms hereof," so the real exit is wherever the rest of the document puts it. The attorneys also note that vendors usually want disputes heard near their own headquarters, which may not be convenient for the center.

"Too often, the language and terms of a contract are only carefully reviewed after an issue arises. By then, it may be too late."

Iain Stauffer and Christopher Dwight, Poyner Spruill, Provider magazine, 2018

Some administrators assume state law will cover them. In Kentucky, KRS 216.724 bars a health care services agency from restricting the employment opportunities of temporary direct care staff, "including but not limited to contract buy-out provisions or contract non-compete clauses." The statute covers temporary direct care staff and does not expressly mention permanent placements such as a Director of Nursing, and most DON searches are direct hire. Before treating a law like this as protection against a firm's buy-out or candidate-ownership terms, ask counsel whether it reaches your hire.

The same attorneys say the negotiation happens on paper. Question pre-filled terms even when a vendor says they cannot change. Refuse a vendor's request to "work it out later." After everyone signs, re-read the final copy so "no unwanted or unexpected extras have appeared."

Across these documents, vendor duties read as effort and buyer duties read as deadlines. A replacement, a fee waiver or a statutory ban can each prove conditional, or miss your hire entirely. A clause's heading tells you little; its verbs and deadlines decide who absorbs the cost of a failed hire.

Five checks before you sign

  1. Circle every effort word in the replacement clause, such as endeavor, commercially reasonable efforts or if necessary, and ask the firm to write in the result it will deliver and by when. Ask whether that promise covers a DON who leaves within the first year.
  2. List every deadline the contract puts on you, including notice of a failed screening or an early departure, and put each one on a contracts calendar.
  3. Read the for-cause and without-cause termination notice periods separately, and look for automatic renewal and a venue clause before you sign.
  4. If your state limits staffing-agency buy-outs, ask counsel whether that law reaches a permanent DON placement before you rely on it.
  5. Question any pre-filled term the firm calls fixed, refuse to work it out later, and re-read the fully signed copy for extras.

How we checked this

We read three publicly posted contracts: two county healthcare staffing agreements and one Texas managed care contract. We also read the text of a Kentucky statute and a 2018 contracting guide that two health law attorneys wrote for long term care providers. No figures in this section come from us. None of the contracts is a DON search agreement, and two of the public copies cut off partway through the clauses we quote, so later text could change their meaning. We read the statute's wording, not any court ruling on it, and nothing here is legal advice. The attorneys advise providers on contracts. We write for the employers who sign these agreements. Still unknown: how DON search firms word their own replacement clauses, because we found none published.

  1. Iain Stauffer and Christopher Dwight, Poyner Spruill, Provider magazine guide to reducing contract risk, November 2018.
  2. Solano County, healthcare staffing agreement on the county records system, undated public copy.
  3. Merced County, staffing agreement in board agenda materials, undated public copy.
  4. Texas Health and Human Services, redacted managed care contract, public copy.
  5. Kentucky Revised Statutes 216.724, statute text on health care services agencies, via FindLaw.

What is a DON search fee calculated on, and when is it owed?

Fees differ by firm, so check what the fee is calculated on and when it is owed, then test that base against public pay data from BLS and CMS.

However a firm sets its rate, the rate is applied to something. That something is the fee base. Before you sign, get a written answer to each of these:

  • What counts as compensation? Base salary only, or base plus sign-on bonus, relocation and any guaranteed raise?
  • Whose number is used? The salary in the offer letter, or a projected first-year total the firm calculates?
  • What earns the fee? Offer acceptance, the start date, or the candidate clearing every screening step?
  • Is anything due up front? If so, is it credited against the final fee, and is it refundable if the search stops?

Conventional wisdom says to negotiate the rate. The base deserves the same attention. The same rate applied to a bigger base is a bigger invoice, and a sign-on bonus you added to close a tight offer can quietly raise what you owe the firm.

The trigger matters as much as the base. A Merced County staffing agreement puts it plainly: "Upon the failure of any Staff to pass such background check, Client shall provide notice to Agency within twenty-four (24) hours, and Client shall have no obligation to pay any Agency fees in relation to such Staff." That clause ties payment to screening. Put that check date on your onboarding calendar the day the offer is signed, and name who in your building owns it. Ask the firm to list every deadline the contract sets for your side, and attach that list to the signed copy.

For a DON, screening is more than a background check. It includes license verification, references and a read of the candidate's survey history. Write the fee trigger so it falls after all of that clears, not at a verbal yes. Then put the notice deadline on your own calendar.

Firms sometimes justify a fee by pointing to what a vacancy costs. Ask where that number came from. Our review found no defensible SNF cost per leadership hire, and the figure often quoted, $60,090 to replace one bedside RN (NSI 2026), is a hospital figure. We dropped a turnover cost calculator from the site for that reason. A hospital number is not your building's number.

Director of Nursing Search builds its pay data from BLS wage data, CMS facility and staffing data and industry surveys, cited on the page, with no sign-up needed, and its hiring help starts with a free 15-minute intro call before any introduction to a specialist recruiting firm. Pull your state's range from that data before you accept any fee base, so you know what the number on the invoice is being multiplied against.

Once you know what the fee is built on and what earns it, the next question is how long you are bound to the firm that charges it, and what it takes to walk away if the slate goes thin by week six.

Not sure an outside search is the right call?

Take the free promote-or-hire quiz before you sign anything. Florida already requires an RN ADON in any nursing home with a census of 121 or more, so your successor may be on the floor today.

If you do hire, the hire-and-retain pay plan ties raises to milestones at 3, 6 and 12 months. Treat it as general guidance and check it with your counsel. When a search makes sense, start with a free 15-minute intro, then, if you agree, an introduction to a specialist recruiting firm that fits the role, state and timeline.

How long are you bound to the firm, and who else can it recruit for?

Before signing, confirm how long exclusivity runs, how either side can exit, how long the firm can claim a candidate, and whether it recruits for competing buildings nearby.

Exclusivity length and the way out

Exclusivity is fair while the firm is doing the work. It turns against you when the search stalls and the contract still says you cannot call anyone else. In a 2018 Provider magazine article, health law attorneys Iain Stauffer and Christopher Dwight of Poyner Spruill warned that a long-term contract "locks in the center, and it could be forced to remain with a poorly performing vendor." They also flagged automatic renewal provisions, which renew a contract for another period unless one party gives notice of nonrenewal inside a defined window.

Read the termination section twice. Termination for cause and termination without cause, also called for convenience, generally carry their own notice periods, and the authors are blunt that those periods can differ: "Never assume that notice periods are the same." Here is what I would ask for in writing:

  • A fixed exclusivity period with a stated end date, not one that runs until a hire is made.
  • A right to end the engagement for convenience on written notice, with the notice period spelled out in days.
  • No automatic renewal. If both sides want more time, sign an extension.

How long the firm owns a candidate it sent you

A candidate ownership clause says that if you hire someone the firm introduced within a set period, you owe the fee. A short window is fair. A long one is not. If your own ADON, or a nurse leader who applied to your building on their own, shows up on the firm's list, you can end up paying for a candidate you already had.

My advice is to ask for two limits. First, a short window measured from the date the firm sent the résumé, not from the date you hire. Second, a carve-out for anyone already on your payroll or in your applicant file before the introduction, with that list attached to the contract.

State law is moving on related terms. Kentucky Revised Statutes 216.724 bars health care services agencies from restricting the employment opportunities of temporary direct care staff, and it names "contract buy-out provisions" and "contract non-compete clauses" among the banned restrictions. That statute covers temporary direct care staff. It does not expressly reach a permanent DON hire. Another state measure goes further on the facility side, adding required provisions to contracts between staffing agencies and health care facilities and raising penalties for violations.

Neither rule writes your DON search contract. Both show where buyer protection is heading. Mark up the exclusivity, ownership and conflict terms on one page, and send that page back to the firm before you discuss any candidate.

Conflict rules for competing local clients

None of the public contracts cited in this guide addresses competing clients, which is exactly why you have to raise it. A DON candidate pool in one county is small. Ask these three questions:

  1. Is the firm running a DON or ADON search for another building in your market right now?
  2. Will it present the same candidate to you and to that building at the same time, and will it tell you when it does?
  3. Will it agree in writing not to recruit your DON or ADON away for a set period after your search closes?

Turnover inside the firm matters too. Recruiters themselves describe clients who stayed with one large agency for years and still worked with many different recruiters. Name the recruiter who will run your search in the contract, and say what happens if that person leaves.

Last, check who signs. A contract signed by someone without authority can still bind the organization. If an owner or regional leader approves search spending in your group, get that signature before the firm starts calling candidates, and put every renewal and notice date on one calendar that someone other than you can see.

What should you do before the next search contract lands on your desk?

Score each of the five terms against the risk it moves, push back on any term that shifts a failed hire onto you, and check every change with counsel.

Here is where I think this goes. The firms that keep independent buildings as clients will be the ones whose paper carries real risk: a replacement duty that binds, a fee that waits for the checks to clear, an exit you can use. Soft promises will get harder to defend at renewal.

The data will not do this work for you. Our October 2026 review of public sources turned up a single DON tenure figure, and it covered one state. No national benchmark tells you how long your next DON will stay. That leaves the contract as the one document where your exposure is written down in plain terms.

So treat it that way. Read the exclusions before the rate. Ask who else the firm is working for in your county. Put the candidate ownership window next to your own hiring calendar and see where they overlap.

Then build the comparison, firm by firm, term by term, starting with the replacement clause.

Summarize This Article With AI

Open this article in your preferred AI engine for an instant summary.

Frequently Asked Questions

What else do administrators ask about DON recruiter contracts?

Most questions come down to cost, negotiation room, disputes and fit for your building type. Each answer below gives you a step to take before you sign.

What does Director of Nursing Search charge for hiring help?

Hiring help starts with a free 15-minute intro call. If a search makes sense and you agree, we introduce a specialist recruiting firm that fits the role, state and timeline. The site is free for employers and candidates, and it earns a referral fee from the recruiting firm when it makes an introduction, as our disclosure page explains. The firm's own terms are set in its contract, so read them against the five terms in this guide, then book the intro.

Can I negotiate a recruiter's standard contract?

Yes. Health law attorneys who advise long term care operators say pre-filled terms should be questioned and negotiated, even when a vendor says they cannot change. Treat the printed form as an opening offer. If a firm refuses to move on anything, that tells you how it will handle a failed hire.

Where would a dispute with a recruiting firm be settled?

Look for two clauses. A dispute resolution clause may send any disagreement to arbitration instead of court. A venue clause sets where a dispute is heard, and vendors typically prefer a location close to their headquarters, which may be far from your building. Both are worth negotiating before you sign.

Should one agreement cover both a DON and an ADON search?

Ask before you assume. Some agreements cover one seat only, and a second search may run on new terms. If your ADON is the likely successor, settle the promote-or-hire question first, because it changes which search you need.

Does an assisted living community need different terms than a skilled nursing facility?

The same five terms apply. What changes is the candidate pool. Ask the firm how many of the candidates it would send have led nursing in assisted living, and get that answer in writing.

Can a pay plan be part of the offer a firm helps negotiate?

It can. Our hire-and-retain pay plan takes about 5 minutes and builds a starting salary with raises tied to milestones. Treat the output as general guidance, not legal, HR or financial advice, and check it with counsel before it goes into an offer letter.

What should I do once the signed contract comes back?

Read the final copy again, line by line, to confirm no unexpected extras appeared. Then put the renewal date, every notice deadline and the end of the candidate ownership window on one calendar, next to your survey window.

Written by

Dorian Hammer

Editor, Director of Nursing Search

Dorian Hammer edits the guides at Director of Nursing Search, written for administrators and owners of skilled nursing facilities and assisted living communities who need to hire or keep a Director of Nursing or ADON.

View profile