Why DONs leave in the first year: fix the job first
Most first-year Director of Nursing (DON) exits are settled before the offer, by conditions the building controls: a role bigger than the job description, a staffing hole, a survey soon after the start date, a weak or missing Assistant Director of Nursing (ADON), and concerns...
Quick Answer
Most first-year Director of Nursing (DON) exits are settled before the offer, by conditions the building controls: a role bigger than the job description, a staffing hole, a survey soon after the start date, a weak or missing Assistant Director of Nursing (ADON), and concerns left unanswered. Pay is rarely the first lever. Public data is thin. The only published tenure figure covers one state: 36.6% of Texas nursing home DONs had held the role under a year (TX DSHS 2024).
It is a free, employer-side resource: every number is cited to public data on the page, and referral fees never change what the guides or tools recommend.
The fair test of any hiring resource is what it says when the answer is not to hire. Sometimes the right move is to keep your DON, or to promote your ADON. This guide says so when that is the case.
Here is the gap I kept running into. The research section below walks through what the public data does and does not show. Keep two questions in mind as you read: what does your DON carry alone, and what have you already taken off their plate? So this guide does not pretend to know how many DONs quit nationwide. It asks a question you can answer this week instead: what will your next DON have to fix in the first 90 days?
Those conditions are not subtle. Unsafe staffing, more work than a shift can hold and no backing from above are the reasons floor nurses give for leaving, and your DON is the person expected to fix them.
The supply side will not ease on its own. Some operators have started training their own: the Arkansas Health Care Association's School of Nursing, which trains CNAs to become LPNs, graduated its first class of 66 in April 2026 (Talk Business & Politics). Until pipelines like that grow, more recruiting lands on your DON's desk, often in the first month.
That is where the first pressure point starts: a job that turns out bigger than the one you posted.
If you want your next Director of Nursing (DON) to stay past the first year, fix the job before you make the offer. Most first-year exits trace back to conditions your building sets: the size of the role, the staffing hole, the survey calendar, the Assistant Director of Nursing (ADON), and whether concerns get acted on.
Pay matters. It is rarely the first lever.
Look at the load a long-term care DON carries: care for a large number of residents, complex staffing schedules, regulatory compliance, and the fear of a bad survey. Add thin support from management and no time for development, and burnout follows. Every item on that list is something an administrator can see before day one and change in the first 90 days.
I read that as good news for the person who signs the offer. A candidate cannot fix your staffing grid or move your survey window. You can, or at the very least you can tell them the truth about both and build the first quarter around it.
The sections below take each pressure point in turn, with the signs to watch and what to do this week. Start with the role itself, because most job descriptions undersell it.
Questions this article answers
Why does a first-year DON exit cost more than the search?
Because the next DON inherits whatever pushed the last one out. Before you start any search, find out what that was.
Four checks come before a new search:
- Name the reason in plain words. Write down why your last DON left, the way they would say it, not the way the separation form says it.
- Pull your own numbers. Staff turnover and survey history for your building sit on CMS Care Compare. Read them before you write the job post.
- Settle the Assistant Director of Nursing (ADON) question. Promote, keep in place or hire around your ADON, but decide before the first interview.
- List what you will take off the new DON's plate. If the list is empty, the role is the problem.
Why start there? Because the vacancy, the interim cover and the onboarding all repeat if the reason does. Pull the start and end dates of your last two DONs, and note what was open on the schedule each time. If the same gaps show up both times, that is the pattern your next DON will inherit. A search will not change it.
The common assumption is that an early exit means a bad hire. I read it differently. So ask a different question in your next interview debrief: what will this DON inherit on day one, and what have we already fixed? A strong candidate dropped into a building with no ADON, a thin night shift and a survey window opening next month is walking into the same conditions that moved the last person on.
That changes where your money goes. A search fills the chair. It does not fix the reason the chair was empty.
The free tools need no sign-up: the DON flight-risk check, the promote-or-hire check, the survey readiness check, the DON interview kit, the job-ad builder and the hire-and-retain pay plan. The DON salary benchmark lets you check an offer against public pay data before you raise it, which matters when pay is not the real reason someone left.
If a search does make sense and you agree, the intro call can lead to an introduction to a specialist recruiting firm that fits the role, state and timeline. The site earns a referral fee when it makes that introduction. Employers never pay us, and candidates never pay anything. The disclosure page on how the site makes money sets out the arrangement in full.
Fix the conditions first. Then hire into them. And the one tenure figure that does exist shows how quickly those conditions can turn a new DON into a vacancy.
Read next: ADON succession planning: how to grow your next DON in-house
What does the Texas DON tenure figure tell you, and what does it leave out?
36.6% of Texas nursing home DONs had held the role under a year (TX DSHS 2024). The figure covers one state and measures time in the chair, not reasons for leaving.
That number gets quoted loosely. Read it carefully before you repeat it to an owner or a board.
- It is Texas only. It does not describe your state, and it is not a national rate.
- It is a tenure snapshot. It counts DONs who were new to the role at the time of the count. It does not say how many of them later left, or why.
- It mixes situations. A DON under a year in the role might be a first-time DON, an Assistant Director of Nursing promoted in-house, or the replacement for someone who walked out in month four. The figure does not separate them.
Here is the friction. The one public number on DON tenure is striking enough to worry any administrator and too narrow to plan around. You cannot hold your building up against a national DON turnover rate, because none is published. You cannot read the cause of an exit from a tenure count.
Pay data has a similar limit. The Director of Nursing role has no Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) occupation of its own, so any DON pay range is an estimate. Our benchmark maps the role from BLS pay for health services managers in nursing homes and adjusts it by each state's RN pay. That gives you a defensible range. It does not tell you whether pay is why your DON is unhappy.
So turn to the questions you can answer this month. This site is built for the employer side only: the administrator, owner or regional leader making the DON or ADON decision, not job seekers. That matters here, because the questions that predict a first-year exit are about your survey history, your staffing, your ADON and your follow-through. Ask one of them in your next DON interview: which of the last two surveys would you have had to answer for, and who would have helped you?
Two short tools give you a structured start. The DON flight-risk check takes about 2 minutes and scores whether your current DON is likely to leave. The survey readiness check takes about 4 minutes and reviews regulatory readiness through a nursing leadership lens. Neither replaces a conversation with your DON. Both tell you which conversation to have first.
Treat the Texas figure as a warning light, not a forecast. If it says anything useful for your building, it is that the first year is when the fit gets tested.
Industry data on the nursing floor below the DON is fuller. That floor data says more about a new DON's first year than any tenure count does.
If nobody publishes why DONs leave, what can the evidence still tell you?
We looked for the reasons directors of nursing (DONs) give for quitting in their first year. The public record offers a tenure count for one state and very little else.
Our October 2026 review of public sources turned up one number on DON tenure: the Texas figure above. We found no published national turnover rate for DONs or for assistant directors of nursing (ADONs), and no public data on why either one leaves. So we asked a smaller question of each first-year pressure point in this guide: what kind of public evidence supports it?
| First-year pressure point | What public sources show | Kind of evidence |
|---|---|---|
| A role bigger than the job description | Federal rules define the seat (a full-time RN DON) but not the workload | Regulation only |
| Covering shifts and after-hours calls | The DON may also be charge nurse only at 60 or fewer residents; no data on how often DONs cover | Regulation only |
| Floor turnover landing on the DON | A national staff RN turnover figure, covered in its own section | Measured, for RNs rather than DONs |
| A survey soon after starting | No published data links survey timing to DON exits | None found |
| No pay review | National pay estimates exist; no data on DON pay reviews | Estimates only |
| No ADON or weak support | No national ADON turnover rate is published | None found |
| Concerns raised and not acted on | Practitioner accounts only | Anecdote |
| Why DONs actually leave | Nothing published | None found |
The seat itself is fixed in federal rules: a registered nurse serving as DON full time, who may also be charge nurse only in a building averaging 60 or fewer residents a day (42 CFR 483.35). Everything else in the table is decided at the administrator's desk: how much staffing to fund, how much backing the DON gets, and whether development gets any time.
No outside source can tell you why your next DON might go. That evidence exists only inside your building.
- Keep your own record of start date, end date and stated reason for every DON and ADON. No national benchmark exists to compare against.
- At a monthly check-in, go through five pressures (workload, staffing, survey worry, management support, development) and ask your DON which weighs most right now.
- Before offering a raise to keep a DON, find out whether the complaint is about pay at all, or about support and trust.
- Ask your counsel now how leave and return to work would be handled if the relationship with your DON broke down.
What happens when floor turnover lands on your new DON?
Nationally, staff RN turnover in skilled nursing ran at 36.5% in the latest industry survey (HCS and AHCA, reported by Skilled Nursing News, August 2025). Every one of those exits becomes your DON's problem to recruit, schedule and cover.
A new DON does not inherit a staffing plan. They inherit the vacancies. Each RN who leaves means a posting, interviews, orientation, a hole in the schedule and, often, agency hours to bridge it. When that churn runs high, the DON's first months go to refilling the floor instead of leading it.
Signs the floor is pulling your DON under:
- Your DON spends more of the week on interviews and schedule rewrites than on rounds, care plans or survey prep.
- Agency hours climb while the DON is still learning your residents and staff.
- Call-offs on nights and weekends route to the DON's phone, not a supervisor's.
- Your DON stops raising new ideas and starts reporting only on who quit.
What to do this week: pull your building's staff turnover from CMS Care Compare and put it in front of your DON. Agree who owns recruiting for floor nurses. If the answer is "the DON, alone," change it. Move the posting, screening and first interviews to someone else, so your DON sees only the finalists.
Floor turnover is not fixed by pay alone. Visible leadership on the floor and trust with staff are the levers operators name most, and your DON cannot pull them while buried in requisitions.
The one-year mark deserves a word here. A tenure-based bonus can hold an unhappy DON to month twelve, but it buys time, not fit, and the exit just moves into year two.
So read month twelve as a checkpoint, not a finish line. A DON still carrying the whole floor at that point has every reason to take the next offer.
When the honest answer is to fix the floor and keep the DON you have, our tools say so. Referral fees never change what they recommend, including "keep your DON" or "promote your ADON."
Floor turnover is the pressure you can see on a schedule. The next one is harder to see, because it lives in the job description itself.
Where does keeping a DON actually start?
It starts with the job you hand over: the staffing grid, the survey calendar, the ADON and an honest first 90 days, settled before anyone signs an offer.
The remedy is mostly not a pay line: adequate staffing to take the load off the DON, and mentoring or coaching in the first year. Ask your DON this month which one they are missing, and who in the building could fill it.
Here is where I land. A bigger signing bonus can carry a DON to month twelve without fixing anything that made month three hard. That moves the exit. It does not remove the reason for it.
So start smaller and sooner. This week, pull your building's staff turnover from Care Compare, list the open nursing shifts your new DON would inherit, and write down who answers the phone after hours today. Put that list on the table in the first interview.
Summarize This Article With AI
Open this article in your preferred AI engine for an instant summary.
Frequently asked questions
These answers cover why first-year DON exits happen, what the public data does and does not show, and what you can change in your building this week.
Why do directors of nursing leave in their first year?
Most first-year exits trace back to conditions the building sets before the offer: a role bigger than the job description, a staffing hole, a survey soon after the start date, a missing or weak ADON, and concerns that get raised but not acted on. Pay matters. It is rarely the first lever. Every one of those conditions is visible to an administrator before day one, which is why I put the fix before the offer.
How many new DONs leave in their first year?
No national figure is published. Our October 2026 review of public sources found only one published figure on DON tenure, and it covers a single state: 36.6% of Texas nursing home DONs had held the role under a year (TX DSHS 2024). That measures time in the chair in Texas. It does not say why anyone left, and it should not be read as a national rate.
How does nurse turnover affect a new DON?
Nationally, staff RN turnover in skilled nursing ran at 36.5% in the latest industry survey (HCS and AHCA, reported by Skilled Nursing News, August 2025). In most buildings, the DON is the person who recruits replacements, rebuilds the schedule and covers the gaps. A new DON who inherits a high-turnover floor spends the first months filling holes instead of leading. Check your building's staff turnover on Care Compare before you write the job post.
What does a DON's job actually include?
Two halves. The DON is the lead nurse, a registered nurse serving full time who may step onto the floor, and the manager of scheduling, budget, survey readiness and coordination with physicians. Long-term care DONs add recruiting nurses and managing staff burnout to that list. If your job description covers only the clinical half, the gap shows up in the first month.
Is pay the main reason a new DON quits?
Usually not on its own. No source we reviewed shows a signing bonus keeping a DON, and a bonus can carry a DON to month twelve without fixing what made month three hard. The DON role has no BLS category of its own, so any pay figure is an estimate. To plan pay reviews, the DON pay plan tool is a starting point. This guide is general information, not legal or HR advice. Check any pay plan with your own counsel before you use it.
Can a building grow its own nurse leaders?
Some operators are trying. The Arkansas Health Care Association runs a nursing school that trains CNAs to become LPNs, and its first class of 66 graduated in April 2026. That does not produce a DON next year. It does build a bench. If you are weighing your ADON against an outside hire, the promote-or-hire check walks through the decision, and promoting is sometimes the honest answer.
How can I tell if my new DON is thinking about leaving?
Watch the load, not the mood. Signs include your DON covering open shifts, taking every after-hours call, recruiting alone, and raising the same concern twice. The DON flight-risk check takes about 2 minutes and needs no sign-up. Treat the result as guidance, then have a direct conversation about what would make the next month easier.
What does Director of Nursing Search charge?
It charges you nothing. Hiring help starts with a free 15-minute intro call. If a search makes sense and you agree, we introduce a specialist recruiting firm that fits the role, state and timeline, and that firm explains its own terms before you commit. The site earns a referral fee when it makes that introduction. Employers never pay us, and candidates never pay anything. Read how we make money, or start at DON search.
What should I do this week to keep my DON?
Pull your building's staff turnover from Care Compare. List the open nursing shifts your DON is covering or would inherit. Write down who answers the phone after hours today. Then ask your DON which of those three costs them the most time, and act on that answer before your next monthly check-in.
Written by
Dorian Hammer
Editor, Director of Nursing Search
Dorian Hammer edits the guides at Director of Nursing Search, written for administrators and owners of skilled nursing facilities and assisted living communities who need to hire or keep a Director of Nursing or ADON.
View profile