Retained vs Contingency Search for a Single SNF DON Seat
For a single DON seat at an independent SNF, choose exclusive contingency with a short exclusivity window and a written replacement clause . Retained search earns its upfront fee on multi-seat or turnaround searches.
Quick Answer
For a single DON seat at an independent SNF, choose exclusive contingency with a short exclusivity window and a written replacement clause. Retained search earns its upfront fee on multi-seat or turnaround searches.
Put the money you keep into the offer: a starting salary and raises tied to first-year milestones. Ask one thing first. If your ADON is ready, promoting from within may beat both models, and I would settle that before any firm calls back.
The search model is the smaller decision. The bigger one is what your building offers the DON who says yes: a starting salary, raises tied to milestones in the first year, and an ADON plan the new hire can see on day one. Our hire-and-retain pay plan builds that offer, and it is general guidance to check with your counsel before you use it.
I put the offer first because the fee argument runs out of facts fast. We dropped a turnover cost calculator from this site after our review found no defensible SNF cost per leadership hire. Treat any vacancy cost quoted for a single building with care, including one inside a retainer pitch.
So this guide does not lean on a cost model. It leans on contract terms you can read, question and get in writing before you sign. It also asks something most search pitches skip. Should you be searching at all? Our Promote or hire? quiz was built to recommend promoting your ADON whenever the answers support it, not to steer every building toward an outside hire.
Then comes the stretch while the seat sits open. Administrators ask whether an interim DON or a short vacancy costs a nursing home less. The public sources I worked from give no cost comparison for nursing homes. The choice turns on your survey window and how much your ADON can carry while a firm works the search, and that is exactly where the exclusivity window and the replacement clause start to earn their place in the contract.
You have one Director of Nursing (DON) seat open at an independent skilled nursing facility (SNF), and two kinds of search firm asking for your signature. My answer for most single-seat buildings is exclusive contingency with a written replacement clause, not a retainer. Retained search earns its upfront fee on multi-seat searches and on turnaround buildings. A single DON seat in a stable building is neither.
The industry's own framing runs the other way. Retained firms describe the DON as a business-critical hire that needs a dedicated, research-heavy process, and that description is accurate. It just does not follow that you should pay before anyone starts.
I will grant the retained side one point. A firm that is paid upfront has a reason to keep calling candidates late in a slow search, and a contingency firm juggling other openings may not. That is a real trade-off. Ask the firm what it would do under a retainer that it will not do under an exclusive contract.
Read the replacement clause before you read the fee line. It is when your money leaves the building, what you get back if the DON resigns in the first year, and how much of the groundwork you finish yourself. Your survey history, your ADON and your pay range sit in that groundwork.
Questions this article answers
Retained or contingency search for a nursing home DON: which works better?
For one DON seat at an independent SNF, exclusive contingency usually works better than retained search. You pay when you hire, not upfront, and one firm still works your search alone.
Before you read the definitions, answer four questions about your building:
- How many nursing leadership seats are you filling this year? One seat points away from a retainer.
- Must the search stay confidential from your current DON or your staff?
- Will the new DON inherit an open plan of correction from your last standard survey?
- Can your own team screen candidates, check references and run interviews?
Contingency search is success-only. The firm is paid if its candidate is hired. In the open version, several agencies work the same DON opening at once and race to send candidates first. Retained search runs the other way. One firm works the search exclusively, and fees are paid upfront and in stages across the search, whether or not you hire. Two hybrids sit between them. Exclusive contingency keeps payment tied to a hire but gives one firm the search alone. Contained search adds a partial upfront payment. Firms that sell it set their own split between the upfront payment and the hire, so ask any firm to put that split, and any candidate timeline it offers, in writing.
The common assumption is that retained search buys a better DON because the firm is paid to try harder. Retained firms make that case themselves. None of their comparisons publishes DON fill rates to back it.
A review of 4 sources on the two models, every one written by a recruiting firm, shows the same pattern. Each recommends the model it sells. Each concedes the other model fits some roles. One sales recruiter even wrote that the final fee is likely the same whichever model you choose, and that the real differences sit in the terms. An older piece from a sales recruiter, written in 2015, offered a plain alternative to a retainer: give one skilled recruiter an exclusive contract for a set period.
That shifts your job. Ask each firm which model it would recommend for your building, and why. You are deciding when your money is at risk and who controls the search.
Know your pay range before you talk to any firm. The 2026 DON salary benchmark gives a starting range by state, so you can judge a candidate slate against public numbers instead of a recruiter's read of the market. If you want outside help, Director of Nursing Search starts with a free 15-minute intro call. If a search makes sense and you agree, it introduces a specialist recruiting firm that fits the role, state and timeline, and it earns a referral fee from that firm when it does.
The upfront fee is where most single-seat buyers take on risk they never priced.
Read next: Why the DON Seat Keeps Emptying: Role Stacking, Not Pay
What are you actually buying when you pick a search model?
A recruiting firm that sells three search models wrote that the final fee "will most likely be the same" whichever one a client picks. So what is a one-building SNF paying for?
In the same 2024 post, the sales recruiter answered its own question: "The differences between these services lie in the terms governing the relationship." We read six pages in which search firms and a retained search advocate compare the models. Each is selling something, yet side by side they kept pointing us to the contract and away from its label.
The labels blur, too. The same firm sells a middle option it calls contained search, with part of the fee paid upfront and the rest on hire. Another sales recruiter markets itself as contingency, charges an initiation fee per hire, and insists the fee is "not a deposit, not a retainer." Two proposals with different names can describe nearly the same deal.
| Model | When you pay | Firms working the search | When the sources say it fits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Contingency, several firms | Only if you hire a firm's candidate | Several, competing | A straightforward role, a large pool, and staff who can screen high applicant volume |
| Exclusive contingency | When you hire | One, for an agreed period | Nuanced mid to senior roles; offered by one recruiter as an alternative to a retainer |
| Contained or hybrid | Part upfront, rest on hire, or an initiation fee | Set by the contract | Manager and director roles, per one firm |
| Retained | Upfront and in stages, whatever the outcome | One, exclusive | High impact, confidentiality, stakeholder complexity and scarcity together; small pools |
Of all those terms, exclusivity most changes how a firm works. When several contingency firms chase one opening, an executive search firm in Asia writes, the result is "a frenzy of resumes, hurried vetting, and a lot of noise," often with one résumé arriving from three sources. Chris Carlson, who founded a sales recruiting firm and has more than two decades in the field, warns that "the better recruiters will want no part of joining a free-for-all," and calls the approach the "kiss of death when there is a limited candidate pool."
Exclusivity, the Asian firm says, "changes everything," because the recruiter stops racing and starts working with you. Carlson suggests an exclusive contract for a set period as an alternative to a retainer. Neither requires paying before a hire.
A retainer still buys something exclusivity does not. Under contingency, notes a retained firm serving nonprofit and mission-driven organizations, the employer keeps "search design, candidate calibration, stakeholder alignment, and process management" largely in-house. Its test asks whether impact, confidentiality, stakeholder complexity and scarcity are all high. If they are, retained is "usually the prudent route." Even a contingency seller concedes retained search can fit pools "measured in dozens rather than thousands." For one DON seat, the harder questions are scarcity and staff time. "The key is to be honest about internal capacity," the nonprofit firm writes.
Once the new DON starts, the sources stop agreeing.
36.6%
Share of Texas nursing home DONs who had held the role for under a year, according to Texas DSHS in 2024. Vendors disagree on what protects you if one leaves early. A contingency seller's comparison table says retained firms offer a replacement window only "Sometimes (90 days)." A retained search advocate says retained deals typically carry 12 months, while contingency recruiters "exit accountability after 90 days." The Texas figure measures time in the seat, so it cannot show when DONs leave, and we found no national DON tenure figure.
In Texas, then, a DON in the first year in the seat is ordinary. Read the window's length and what ends it line by line, whatever the model is called.
The sellers' numbers cannot settle the choice. Carlson publishes his firm's own fill rates for both models while noting that "definitive industry success rates for retained searches are unavailable." The retained advocate presents his failure rates for executive hires as his own observations, without naming a study. And one firm counts a candidate as qualified "if a customer agrees to meet with them."
With the labels set aside, several benefits retained sellers describe, a committed recruiter and an end to the résumé race, are ones the sources also credit to exclusivity, which needs no money upfront. Protection after the start date hangs on a window the vendors cannot agree on. A retainer's clearest extra is a firm that designs and runs the search for you, help that matters most when the pool is thin or nobody in the building has the hours.
Five questions before you sign
- Will the firm define a qualified candidate in writing, and say what triggers a refund of any money paid before a hire?
- Can one firm have the seat on an exclusive contract for an agreed period, instead of several firms working it at once?
- How long does the replacement window run, when does it start, and does it cover both a resignation and a dismissal?
- Who in your building will write the role profile, screen candidates and run finalist interviews? If nobody can and the local pool looks thin, what would a retained firm's staged fee buy that an exclusive contract would not?
- When a firm quotes a fill rate or success rate, how was it counted, and over which searches?
How we checked this
We read six pages published between 2015 and 2026 by recruiting firms and a retained search advocate. The firms cover sales recruiting, executive search in energy and infrastructure, and nonprofit executive search. Each sells one or more of the models it compares, and none writes about nursing homes or DON searches. None of their performance figures is independently checked. The Texas tenure figure is a Texas DSHS statistic from 2024 that we found in our own October 2026 review of public sources. None of the numbers here are ours. We name one source firm only generically because it is connected to a company in our field. We earn a referral fee when we introduce an employer to a specialist recruiting firm, so we have a stake in how employers think about search, as our disclosure page explains. We still don't know how either model performs on DON searches, how replacement windows are usually written in DON search contracts, or how long DONs stay nationally.
- Adam Morris, SalesFirst Recruiting, post on contingent, contained and retained search, January 2024.
- Kepler Search, comparison of retained, contingency and exclusive recruitment, June 2025.
- A retained executive search firm serving nonprofit and mission-driven organizations, blog post on retained versus contingency search, June 2026 (not linked).
- HyperHired, comparison page on retained search, undated.
- Craig Devereaux, LinkedIn essay on retained and contingency search, February 2026.
- Chris Carlson, Sales Talent Inc, post on retained sales search, first published October 2015 and citing 2024 figures.
- Texas Department of State Health Services, 2024 figure on nursing home DON tenure, as found in our October 2026 review of public sources.
Which contract terms do single-seat SNF buyers overlook?
Our review found no defensible SNF cost per leadership hire. So judge a search contract by what you lose if the search fails or the DON leaves early, not by a vendor's cost figure.
That matters because cost-of-a-bad-hire numbers fill the sales pages. The $60,090 figure often quoted for replacing one bedside RN (NSI, 2026) is a hospital number, not a nursing home one, and it says nothing about a DON. We dropped a turnover cost calculator from this site for exactly that reason. A number built for a hospital floor will not price your building's risk.
Read these six terms before you sign anything:
- Upfront money owed regardless of outcome. A retained search usually asks for part of its fee before any candidate is presented, and that money is owed whether or not you hire. Ask any firm for its own figure in writing, and ask which stage payments are due if you stop the search.
- The replacement clause. Ask what triggers it, how long it runs and whether it covers a resignation as well as a termination. The vendors disagree openly here. A contingency seller says retained firms offer replacement only sometimes, for 90 days. A retained advocate says retained work carries 12-month replacement terms while contingency recruiters exit after 90 days. Neither cites a source.
- The exclusivity window. Get the start date, the end date and what happens to the search when it closes.
- The fee base. Find out what the fee is calculated on: base salary only, or salary plus sign-on bonus and other pay.
- Candidate ownership. Decide in writing who is owed a fee if two firms present the same nurse, or if a candidate applies to you directly.
- Cancellation. Spell out what you owe if you promote your ADON halfway through the search.
The replacement clause is the one I would read twice. For a single seat, it is your only protection after the offer. Its length should be measured against how long a new DON in your building actually stays, not against a sales page.
A retainer moves risk onto your building on day one. A contingency fee moves it onto the firm until someone starts. With one seat and no second search to spread the cost across, that timing is most of the difference.
Leadership turnover pressure shows up in the trade press every week, and our long-term care news feed keeps a running record of staffing and survey stories across the sector.
Have your own counsel or HR adviser read the final agreement. These terms are guidance, not legal advice, and every firm writes them differently. The firm should explain its terms before you commit, and you should get every one of them on paper. The harder question comes before the contract: whether you need a firm at all.
What should you settle before you call any search firm?
Settle the promote-or-hire question first. The Promote or hire? quiz takes about 2 minutes and tests whether an internal candidate is ready for the DON seat.
Neither search model protects you from an early exit. What protects you is the work you finish before a recruiter's contract sets the terms. On a limited budget, that work is also where you save. Every step you finish in-house is one you are not paying a retainer to cover.
Work through these five steps in order:
- Test your ADON. Run the Promote or hire? quiz with your ADON in mind. We built it to recommend internal promotion whenever the answers support it, instead of always concluding that you should hire from outside. If it says promote, you may not need a search at all.
- Benchmark the pay. The DON pay benchmark is built from public sources cited on the page: BLS wage data, CMS facility and staffing data, and industry surveys. The DON role has no BLS category of its own, so treat any figure as an estimate, not a quote.
- Build the offer before you need it. The hire-and-retain pay plan takes about 5 minutes. It builds a DON starting salary plus tranche-style raises tied to milestones at 3, 6 and 12 months. We present that output as general guidance, not legal, HR or financial advice, so check it with your counsel before you put it in an offer letter.
- Write the job ad and the interview. The free DON job-ad builder and the DON interview kit give you a posting and a question set built for your building, so a firm is working from your definition of the role, not its own.
- Check where your building stands at survey. The survey-readiness check covers nursing leadership readiness for state survey. Pair it with your last two standard surveys from Care Compare. A DON walking into an open plan of correction needs different experience than one walking into a clean building.
Two of those steps change the search model you need. If the quiz points to your ADON, the question becomes how to support a promotion, not which firm to hire. If the survey work shows a turnaround, you are now looking at the one kind of single-seat search where a retainer can earn its keep.
The rest changes what you are buying. A firm that receives a finished job ad, a pay range, a milestone pay plan and a clear account of your survey history is doing a narrower job. Narrow work suits a contingency fee. It also gives you something to measure candidates against when the first slate arrives, and the free DON flight-risk quiz helps you check whether the DON you already have is likely to stay before you replace anyone.
That leaves one decision the tools cannot make for you: whether your seat is the rare one that justifies money upfront.
So which search model should a one-seat SNF choose?
Pick the model whose money you can afford to lose if the DON leaves early, and get its replacement terms in writing. If your ADON is ready, skip the search.
The data behind every DON decision is thin. Our October 2026 review of public sources found only one figure on DON tenure, and it covers Texas only. We found no published national DON or ADON turnover rate. Nobody can tell you how long your next DON will stay.
That is why I would not prepay for certainty. A retainer pays for effort before you know whether the fit holds. A replacement clause pays only if it does not.
So spend the first week on what you control. Test your ADON. Set the pay range. Read your last survey. Then sign for exclusivity, put the replacement terms on paper, and save your cash for the first 90 days your new DON will spend in the building.
Summarize This Article With AI
Open this article in your preferred AI engine for an instant summary.
Frequently Asked Questions
What else do administrators ask about paying for a DON search?
Most follow-up questions come down to money and timing: what a one-seat building can afford, when a retainer earns its fee, and what happens while the seat sits empty.
What if my budget cannot cover a retained search fee?
Then do not stretch for one. A single seat rarely needs it. Ask for exclusive contingency instead: one firm works the search alone for a set exclusivity window and is paid only if you hire its candidate. Put the money you kept into the offer and the first-year raises, because that is what your DON lives with after the search ends.
When is a retained search worth the upfront money?
When you are filling several leadership seats at once, or rebuilding nursing leadership after a hard survey. Those searches need a firm committed for months. One stable seat usually does not.
Should I leave the DON seat open or bring in an interim DON?
The public sources behind this guide do not compare the cost of the two for nursing homes. I would decide on your ADON and your survey window. If a standard survey could land while the seat is empty, interim cover gives you someone accountable for nursing leadership. If your ADON can hold the floor, a short gap may cost less.
What does Director of Nursing Search charge?
Nothing. Employers never pay us, and candidates never pay anything. Hiring help starts with a free 15-minute intro call. If a search makes sense and you agree, we introduce a specialist recruiting firm that fits the role, state and timeline. That firm pays us a referral fee, as our disclosure page explains, and it sets out its own terms before you commit. You can book a free 15-minute intro when you are ready.
How do I start hiring a DON for my nursing home?
Start with your own building, not a firm. Read your last survey. Decide whether your ADON is a candidate, and set the pay range before anyone sends a résumé, so the firm searches against a written offer instead of a guess.
Written by
Dorian Hammer
Editor, Director of Nursing Search
Dorian Hammer edits the guides at Director of Nursing Search, written for administrators and owners of skilled nursing facilities and assisted living communities who need to hire or keep a Director of Nursing or ADON.
View profile