A 30-Day Plan for Hiring a DON Without a Recruiter

Yes. One leader owns the search, four channels feed it, and every finalist's past buildings get checked on CMS Care Compare before the offer. That is a 30-day DON hire without a recruiter .

Quick Answer

Yes. One leader owns the search, four channels feed it, and every finalist's past buildings get checked on CMS Care Compare before the offer. That is a 30-day DON hire without a recruiter.

Plan it without benchmarks. Our review of public sources found no national DON or ADON turnover rate and no defensible SNF cost for a leadership hire. What you can check is the survey record of each building a finalist has already run.

Did this answer your question?
Three things people believe. Myth or fact?
Call each one, then see how other readers called it.
1 Without a search firm, an independent SNF has to hire its next DON from outside.
2 The federal nurse staffing rule is still being fought in court.
3 Sorting the first wave of DON applicants is work only a recruiting firm can do.

Start with what your building already has: its own survey record, CMS Care Compare, a pay range set from public data, and a fixed interview. None of it costs a fee.

I would skip any tool that hands you a dollar figure for what a DON vacancy costs your facility. We dropped our own turnover cost calculator for that reason. The figure most often quoted, $60,090 to replace one bedside RN (NSI 2026), is a hospital number. Our review found no defensible SNF cost per leadership hire, so we now cite cost data only as labeled, sourced statistics, never as a result for one building.

Tenure data has the same hole. Our October 2026 review of public sources turned up one DON tenure figure, and it covers a single state. There is no published national DON or ADON turnover rate to plan against. You are working without a benchmark.

So the tools worth a place in a 30-day plan are the ones that force a decision, not a forecast. The promote-or-hire quiz comes first, because it was built to recommend promoting your ADON whenever the answers support it, rather than always pointing you outside. The interview kit sets the questions for week three. Care Compare carries week four, and it is the step most self-run searches leave out, which is why the plan below starts by naming the one person who owns every week of it.

You can hire a Director of Nursing (DON) for an independent skilled nursing facility (SNF) without paying a search fee. It takes 30 days, one owner, four sourcing channels, and a check of every finalist's past buildings on CMS Care Compare before the offer.

The decision in front of you is not really recruiter or no recruiter. It is whether your building can do the recruiter's work for a month. A search firm's first job is filtering. In 2016, hiring stories shared online described businesses with very small HR departments using recruiting firms to sift the first wave of applications. If you can do that sifting, you can keep the fee.

The stakes are higher than they were. The industry's main trade group has asked CMS to count an RN DON's hours toward round-the-clock RN coverage, which pulls the seat closer to the floor and closer to survey.

A candid note. No public data tells you how often a self-run DON search works. I would not trust anyone who quotes a success rate. What you can control is the order of the work, and that order starts with a decision about your ADON on day one.

Questions this article answers

Stuck at day 30 with no finalist you trust?

Start with a free 15-minute intro. If a search makes sense and you agree, we introduce a specialist recruiting firm that fits the role, state and timeline.

The site is free, and it earns a referral fee only when it makes that introduction. See how we make money.

Who owns a recruiter-free DON search, and what gets decided in week one?

One leader owns it: the administrator or regional leader who signs the offer. Week one is for the decisions only that person can make, starting with whether your ADON is ready.

Settle these five things before anyone posts a job ad:

  1. Name one owner. The administrator runs the plan and holds a standing weekly check-in with HR and the nursing lead.
  2. Test your ADON first. Run the promote-or-hire quiz, which takes about 2 minutes, before you decide to search outside.
  3. Decide what the seat covers on the floor. Is this an administrative leader, or an RN DON whose hours help cover RN shifts?
  4. Set a pay range from public data. Do it now, not after a finalist names a number.
  5. Pull your own survey history. Know what the new DON will have to fix in the first 90 days.

The common assumption is that an open DON seat means an outside search. Often it does not. We built our Promote or hire? quiz to recommend internal promotion whenever the answers support it, instead of always concluding that you should hire from outside. If your ADON passes, the cheapest search is the one you never run. If the ADON falls short on one or two points, you now know exactly what to screen outside candidates for.

The floor question matters more than it used to. An AHCA court filing contrasts the statute's RN coverage of "8 consecutive hours, 7 days a week" with the CMS directive to have an RN "onsite 24 hours per day, for 7 days a week." That fight is not settled. Your job ad still has to say whether the DON works the floor. Candidates read that line closely.

Pay is the second decision that cannot wait. The DON role has no BLS category of its own, so every pay figure you see is an estimate. Our benchmark is built from public sources cited on the page: BLS wage data, CMS facility and staffing data, and industry surveys. Start with the DON salary benchmark for your state, then set a range your budget can hold through the first year, not just the offer.

A read of 4 sources for this section points one way. The choices that shape a DON search sit with the person who signs the offer. Our tools are built for that person, the administrator, owner or regional leader making the DON or ADON decision, not for job seekers. In practice, the administrator who wants to avoid overpaying a recruiter has to do the recruiter's first job: decide what the building needs before looking at a single resume.

Short version for your calendar. Monday, ADON conversation. Tuesday, quiz and survey pull. Wednesday, pay range and floor role. By Friday, the ad is written and the real question shifts to where DON candidates actually are when nobody is paid to find them.

Why is a DON seat harder to fill now, and where do self-run searches stall?

Skilled nursing RN turnover runs about 36.5%, so the pool of nurses ready to lead a building is small and always moving. Week two is where you feel it.

That 36.5% RN turnover figure comes from HCS and AHCA data for 2025. It covers RNs across skilled nursing, not DONs. Still, it tells you what your applicant pool looks like. Fewer RNs build the years in one building that a DON seat asks for. The candidates who have those years are usually employed, busy and not reading job boards.

Nurses who work in these buildings describe a job that changed after COVID. In one large metro area, they say SNFs were once staffed by their own employees, and now a resident commonly sees a different agency nurse each day of the week. CNA shortages land on the DON's desk. Training cannot fix performance when agency staff fill a high share of shifts. A DON candidate knows all of this. Expect the first question in any call to be about your agency hours.

Then there is the staffing rule. CMS's 2024 federal Final Rule requires total nurse staffing of at least 3.48 hours per resident day, including 0.55 RN hours per resident day. The court challenge to it argues the rule applies "regardless of its residents' actual needs." Separately, AHCA's comment letter on the rule recommends that "the DON be counted toward the 24/7 RN requirement," because RN DONs are available for consultation, assessment and evaluation of resident condition.

Contrary to the old picture of the DON as an office job, the staffing debate is pulling the seat back toward RN coverage. Candidates notice. Some will want a role that counts their hours on the floor. Others will walk away from one. Your week one decision on the floor role filters them for you, but only if the ad says it plainly. To track how the rule case moves while you search, keep an eye on the staffing rule coverage in our long-term care news feed.

Self-run searches tend to stall at four points:

  • The ad pulls volume, not leaders. Nobody filters the first wave, so the administrator spends week two reading resumes from nurses who have never run a survey.
  • The best candidates never see the ad. They are working, and they move when someone calls them.
  • The building's record speaks first. High agency hours or a rough survey history end the conversation before a phone screen, unless you raise them yourself.
  • Pay gets set late. A finalist names a number, and the range moves to match it.

None of these needs a search fee to fix. Before week two starts, write the name of the person who owns each of these four problems next to it on the plan.

Where are the DON candidates a self-run search keeps missing?

Try to find out how often nursing home DONs change jobs across the country and you hit a wall. In our review of public sources, only one state had published a number.

The figure comes from the Texas health department. We searched public sources in October 2026 and found no national DON or ADON turnover rate at all, so no administrator can say how big the pool really is.

36.6%

Share of Texas nursing home DONs who had held the role for under a year (Texas DSHS, 2024). It was the only published figure on DON tenure we found.

So where do all those first-year DONs come from? One large operator has a deliberate answer. On the Digital Recruiter Podcast in October 2025, Mike Dickinson, director of recruiting at NHS Management, described how his organization trains its own nursing leaders. The company owns and operates 44 skilled nursing facilities across Alabama, Florida and Arkansas. He put the climb at 5 to 10 years, from entry-level hourly pay to a six-figure salary.

One operator's ladder to the DON seat

  1. Entry-level nursing assistant, trained toward certification
  2. CNA
  3. LPN, through employer-supported nursing school
  4. RN
  5. Unit manager
  6. DON

Source: NHS Management's director of recruiting, Digital Recruiter Podcast, October 2025.

A ladder takes years to build, and people can climb it and then leave. In a February 2025 r/nursing thread, one nurse said they had seen LPNs work as acting DON while finishing RN degrees at company expense, then leave for ICU jobs. That is one person's observation, and the same commenter admitted they did not know the job's current requirements. Still, it gives a self-run search its first question: who in your building has already climbed to the RN rung, and what would make them stay?

The RN rung matters more since the fight over federal staffing rules. CMS's Final Rule set nationwide floors for nurse staffing. AHCA, the nursing home trade association, challenged the rule in federal court, arguing that it applies "regardless of its residents' actual needs."

RequirementStatute, as quoted in AHCA's filingsFinal Rule challenged by AHCA
RN on site8 consecutive hours, 7 days a week24 hours a day, 7 days a week
Total nurse staffing"sufficient to meet the nursing needs" of residentsAt least 3.48 hours per resident day
RN staffingNo fixed figure in the filings we readAt least 0.55 hours per resident day

In its formal comments on the rule, AHCA also argued that the DON's own time should count: "AHCA recommends that the DON be counted toward the 24/7 RN requirement," because DONs "who are RNs are available for consultation, assessment, and evaluation of resident condition." The filings we read do not show how the case ended. Either way, AHCA's argument covers only DONs who hold an RN license, so the license now affects the staffing math as well as the résumé.

Outside the building, Dickinson's experience points to a second weak spot. He said that over the last couple of years, Indeed spend past a certain point has stopped paying off for his team and brings in duplicate applicants. He would rather move that money into video and recruitment branding, though he said his CEO holds that if the jobs aren't on Indeed, the company is failing. His co-host compared a healthy channel mix to a pie chart and warned that relying on one board leaves recruiters at its mercy. Dickinson also told of a vendor that pitched an AI tool able to list every nurse in Florida. The state health department already makes that data publicly available on its website.

A finalist's last building can explain why they want to move. "Since COVID, it's normal for a typical nursing facility resident to see a different agency nurse each day of the week," wrote one r/nursing commenter from a large metro area. Others in the thread said the job was always this hard. These are individual accounts and prove no trend.

Look at the findings side by side and the shape of the problem appears. The pool is thin and turns over quickly. The RN credential narrows it further. And many of the strongest candidates sit one rung below the seat, in your building or a nearby one, where a single job board rarely reaches. None of our sources measured which channel produces DONs who stay, so treat a balanced mix as practitioner advice rather than proof.

  • Before you write the job ad, list every RN in your building at unit manager or ADON level, run the strongest through our promote-or-hire quiz, and promote if the answers support it.
  • Ask an internal candidate directly what would keep them in the building once they hold the RN license.
  • Ask your counsel how your DON's hours fit your RN coverage plan while the federal rule is contested, and confirm each finalist's RN license.
  • Split week-two sourcing across internal candidates, one job board and direct outreach to nurses in nearby buildings. Count the duplicate applicants the board sends, and check whether your state publishes nurse license data before you pay anyone for a list.
  • Ask each finalist how long they held each DON seat and how many shifts in their last building ran on agency staff.

How we checked this

We drew on a podcast interview with a skilled nursing recruiting director, a frontline nurses' discussion thread, three AHCA documents from the federal staffing rule fight (two court filings and a comment letter), and our own October 2026 review of public sources, which produced the Texas DON tenure figure. The ladder and the job-board experience come from one operator. The agency-staffing accounts are anecdotes from anonymous commenters. AHCA is a trade association arguing one side of a lawsuit, and the filings we read do not show the outcome. We earn a referral fee when we introduce an employer to a recruiting firm, as our disclosure page explains. A recruiter-free search earns us nothing. Still unknown: national DON and ADON turnover, and which sourcing channel produces DONs who stay.

  1. Digital Recruiter Podcast, episode 104 with Mike Dickinson of NHS Management, October 31, 2025.
  2. r/nursing, thread on whether the SNF DON job has gotten harder, February 18, 2025.
  3. AHCA, complaint challenging the minimum staffing Final Rule, Case 2:24-cv-00114-Z-BR, 2024.
  4. AHCA, motion for summary judgment in the staffing case, October 2024.
  5. AHCA, comment letter on the minimum staffing proposed rule, undated.
  6. Director of Nursing Search, review of public sources on DON tenure, October 2026, citing Texas DSHS, 2024.

How do weeks three and four turn finalists into a DON who stays?

Week three is a panel interview built from a DON interview kit. Week four checks each finalist's past buildings on Care Compare, then sets an offer with milestone raises.

Week three, owned by the administrator. Bring in clinical voices: the medical director, your ADON if they are not a candidate, and one charge nurse. Use the same questions for every finalist so you can compare answers, not impressions. Our free DON interview kit sits alongside the job-ad builder, the promote-or-hire quiz, the DON flight-risk quiz, the survey-readiness check and the hire-and-retain pay plan, and the kit builds questions around your building rather than a generic list.

One question I would not skip. Federal law asks for nursing services "sufficient to meet the nursing needs" of a facility's residents, and the court challenge to the staffing rule leans on exactly that wording. Ask each finalist how they decide staffing on a hard week: by a fixed number, or by what the residents on each unit need that day. A candidate who can walk you through a real schedule decision, step by step, is showing you clinical judgment. A candidate who only quotes ratios is showing you a policy binder.

Week four, owned by the administrator with HR. This is the step most self-run searches skip, and it is the one that protects your survey record. Before any offer, check where each finalist has led before:

  1. Ask for every building where they served as DON or ADON, with start and end dates.
  2. Look up each building on CMS Care Compare and read the inspection history for the years they were there.
  3. Note the nursing tags, any complaint surveys and whether a plan of correction followed.
  4. Ask the finalist to tell you the story: what was cited, what they changed, what the revisit found.

A deficiency on a past building is not a disqualifier. Silence about it is. A DON who led a building through a plan of correction and can explain the fix may be the right hire for a building with its own tags to clear.

Then the offer. Our hire-and-retain pay plan takes about 5 minutes and builds a DON starting salary plus tranche-style raises tied to milestones at 3, 6 and 12 months. Treat it as general guidance, not legal, HR or financial advice, and check the structure with your own counsel before it goes in a letter. Milestone raises give a new DON a reason to stay through the hardest stretch of the first year.

Before you sign, run the DON flight-risk quiz on the conditions your new hire will walk into. Referral fees never change what our tools recommend, and that includes telling you to keep the DON you have or promote your ADON. If the answers point to fixing the building first, fix the building first, because the next offer letter is only as strong as the first 90 days behind it.

What will a recruiter-free DON search look like a year from now?

Much the same, started earlier. The question to settle now is whether your next DON will work the floor as an RN or only run the building.

I expect the job itself to shift under you. The industry's main trade group has asked CMS to count the hours of a DON who is an RN as RN hours for staffing compliance. If that view holds, a DON who works the floor is worth more to a thin RN bench than one who only runs meetings. Test for it in the panel interview now. Do not wait for the rule to settle.

None of this needs a budget line. The tools, pay data and guides on Director of Nursing Search are free to use with no sign-up, employers never pay us, and candidates never pay anything. Take the promote-or-hire quiz before day one, block an hour in week four for Care Compare, and have your ADON pull the last two surveys for your own building before the first finalist asks about them.

Summarize This Article With AI

Open this article in your preferred AI engine for an instant summary.

Frequently Asked Questions

What else do administrators ask about hiring a DON without a recruiter?

Most questions come down to three things: who does the screening a firm would do, what to put in writing, and what outside help costs you.

Can a building with no HR department screen DON applicants itself?

Yes. In a 2016 Reddit thread among systems administrators, one commenter described a local recruiter as "a resume filter and someone to handle negotiations." Those are two jobs. One owner with a fixed screen and a pay range set in week one can do both.

What happens if a candidate applies directly and through a firm?

Settle it before it happens. A commenter in that same 2016 thread warned that employers may drop a candidate entirely to avoid any claim that a fee is owed. If you use any firm, get its rule on duplicate submissions in writing, and have your counsel read it.

What is a direct hire?

A direct hire means the DON joins your payroll. There is no agency markup on hours and no contract to renew.

Should milestone raises go in the offer letter?

I would put them in. The hire-and-retain pay plan sets raises at fixed points in the first year. Treat it as general guidance, not legal or HR advice, and check it with counsel before it goes out.

What does Director of Nursing Search charge?

Nothing. Hiring help starts with a free 15-minute intro call, and if a search makes sense and you agree, we introduce a specialist recruiting firm that fits the role, state and timeline. We earn a referral fee from that firm when we make the introduction; employers never pay us and candidates never pay anything, as our referral fee disclosure explains. The firm sets its own terms and walks you through them before you sign anything.

Written by

Dorian Hammer

Editor, Director of Nursing Search

Dorian Hammer edits the guides at Director of Nursing Search, written for administrators and owners of skilled nursing facilities and assisted living communities who need to hire or keep a Director of Nursing or ADON.

View profile