The DON Flight-Risk Ladder: Three Stages Before a Resignation

A Director of Nursing usually shows flight risk in three steps you can see: skipping optional meetings, putting complaints in writing, then handing duties to the ADON. Act on the first step.

Quick Answer

A Director of Nursing usually shows flight risk in three steps you can see: skipping optional meetings, putting complaints in writing, then handing duties to the ADON. Act on the first step.

At that point you are negotiating workload, not a counteroffer. Behavior beats mood. A DON can still run a clean morning meeting and be on the way out. Our DON flight-risk check scores the signs, and if the answer is a transition, the promote-or-hire quiz tests your ADON first.

Did this answer your question?
Three things administrators believe about DON flight risk. Myth or fact?
Call each one, then see how other readers called it.
1 Surveyors may ask how often your nursing leadership has changed.
2 A promote-or-hire tool will always tell you to hire from outside.
3 You can get a first read on your DON's flight risk in minutes.

Watch three things in order: optional meetings your DON stops attending, concerns that start arriving in writing, and duties that quietly move to the ADON. Each step narrows your options.

Mood is a poor signal. Behavior you can see from your own office is a better one. A Director of Nursing (DON) who still runs stand-up, signs off the MDS schedule and answers the surveyor can be halfway out the door, and nothing in the morning meeting will tell you.

The order matters more than any single sign. On the first rung, you are talking about workload, not a counteroffer: which committee seats can go, which reports your Assistant Director of Nursing (ADON) can own with support, and what has to come off your DON's plate before the next survey window opens. That is a cheaper conversation than a raise. It is also a more honest one.

By the third rung, the conversation has changed. You are planning coverage.

Our DON flight-risk check scores those signs from what you can observe, not from how your DON says things are going. If the answers point toward a transition, our promote-or-hire quiz tests whether your ADON is ready, and it was built to recommend promoting from inside whenever the answers support it. I would rather you keep a DON you already have, or promote an ADON who already knows your building, than start a search you did not need.

If duties have already drifted, the next decision is who holds the seat while you look: an interim DON, an acting ADON, or nobody at all, and that last choice shows up at survey.

Your decision is whether to act now or wait for a letter. Act now: DON flight risk climbs three visible steps, and on the first one you are negotiating workload, not a counteroffer.

The stakes are on your Care Compare page. A 2025 peer-reviewed study of nursing home leadership turnover found that DON turnover was consistently associated with lower star ratings, by 2.9 to 11.5 percentage points, and with consumer satisfaction scores lower by 0.4% to 1.5%. Those are associations from regression models, not proof of cause. Still, the gap in the star rating is far wider than the gap in family satisfaction. Families notice later. CMS notices sooner.

The three steps are plain. First, your DON pulls back from meetings nobody required. Second, complaints start arriving in writing. Third, duties drift quietly to the ADON.

Each step is observable from your office. None needs a survey of your DON's feelings.

Our DON flight-risk check takes about 2 minutes and scores where your DON stands. If the answer points to a transition, our Promote or hire? quiz tests whether your ADON is ready, and it was built to recommend internal promotion whenever the answers support it. If you want a second read on your building first, our survey readiness check takes about 4 minutes and looks at regulatory readiness through a nursing leadership lens.

Questions this article answers

Why should you watch your DON for flight risk before anything breaks?

Skilled nursing RN turnover runs about 36.5%, and your DON carries every one of those exits on the schedule, at stand-up and in front of the surveyor.

That figure comes from HCS and AHCA data for 2025. It describes the nurses your DON leads, not the DON. But it sets the pressure your DON works under every week. Before you read further, pull three things from your own building:

  1. Your DON's recent calendar. Mark the optional meetings they used to attend and have stopped attending.
  2. Every written escalation this quarter. Emails or memos your DON sent you or corporate about staffing, agency hours or CNA accountability, and whether each one got an answer.
  3. The ADON's task list. Write down what your ADON now runs that your DON owned when they started.

Those three lists are the raw material for everything that follows. Keep them on your desk.

The common assumption is that a DON who says things are fine is fine. The research says otherwise. In 2021, a study published in the Journal of Nursing Management found that approximately half of nursing home managers reported moderate to high emotional exhaustion and cynicism, yet still rated their own efficacy high. In that same 2021 study, 16.6% of managers reported working overtime. The authors concluded that nursing home managers are at significant risk for burnout.

Read that twice. Confidence and exhaustion sat side by side. A DON can run a clean med pass review, answer every survey question, and still be halfway out the door. Asking "how are you holding up?" in a one-on-one will get you the confident answer. It will not get you the exhausted one.

Then put the same three lists side by side again next month and note what moved. At your next one-on-one, ask your DON a plain question: which standing meeting would you drop first if you could?

That is the reason Director of Nursing Search built a DON flight-risk quiz alongside its promote-or-hire quiz and survey-readiness check. It scores behavior you can see from the administrator's office. It can also come back with a plain answer you may not expect: keep your DON, and fix the workload.

Workload and pay often get tangled in the same conversation. If pay is part of what your DON raises, check the DON salary benchmark for your state before you respond. The DON role has no BLS category of its own, so any pay figure is an estimate and should be treated as guidance, not a ceiling.

Pay rarely comes up first, though. Before that conversation, decide which report or committee you could take off your DON's plate this month, so you have something concrete to offer besides money.

Can you see a DON's resignation coming before she hands it in?

A nursing home manager can be worn out, cynical and still convinced she is doing her job well. A 2021 study suggests that mix is common, which makes performance a poor early warning.

The study appeared in the peer-reviewed Journal of Nursing Management and looked at burnout among nursing home managers. About half reported moderate to high emotional exhaustion and cynicism, and 16.6% reported working overtime. They still rated their own efficacy highly. To the authors, that pattern means "managers are at significant risk for burnout."

The study measured burnout. It did not follow anyone through to a resignation, so it cannot say who quit. A DON who keeps hitting her numbers may still be running on reserves. Steady results show the work is done and say little about its cost to her.

Where a departure does show up is afterward. A 2025 study of nursing home leadership turnover used multivariable regressions and found that DON turnover was "consistently associated" with lower star ratings and with lower consumer satisfaction scores. The two associations were very different in size.

Star ratings, low end of range 2.9 points lower
Star ratings, high end of range 11.5 points lower
Consumer satisfaction, low end of range 0.4% lower
Consumer satisfaction, high end of range 1.5% lower
Where DON turnover registers. Reported ranges for the association between DON turnover and two nursing home outcomes, from a peer-reviewed study published in September 2025. The two outcomes use different units, so compare the bars only roughly.

An association does not prove that losing a DON lowers the stars. A building that is already struggling could lose its DON and its rating for the same underlying reasons. Surveyors look for the link anyway. Robin Blyer runs RB Health Partners, a firm that has worked in long-term care compliance for close to 24 years. She expects CMS to ask "how many directors of nursing has the building had?" over the last three years, then read the citation history from the same period and ask whether the leadership changes mattered. "And of course the answer is yes," she said on a December 2025 podcast. While working with one client for a short time, she met "four administrators, four directors of nursing, and three corporate VPs of clinical services."

So if mood and results arrive too late, what shows up earlier? Blyer's answer is paper. When a facility is struggling, one of the first things she checks is its grievance program, because "if you don't ask people, then they'll find a way to tell." Recently she found a facility whose program had no written resolution step under F-tag 585. The federal rule behind that tag, 42 CFR 483.10, requires a Grievance Official who tracks grievances "through to their conclusion" and issues written decisions. That rule covers residents and families, not a DON's complaints about her own job. Blyer's warning still applies to staff. When nobody asks about a concern, it tends to come back later, in writing, and sometimes as a call to the state.

A 2011 post on a legal question site shows how a written record can come before silence. A department head at a long-term care facility said they had visited the DON's office "approximately eight times over six months" about care problems, documented every visit, and taken the issue to the CEO. After a heated exchange and a series of warnings, the employee stopped speaking up: "I've just done my job and gone home." That is one person's account, from someone who reported to a DON. Still, the written complaints came first and the withdrawal came after, which is the reverse of the order our ladder suggests.

Three rungs, watched in any order

  1. Pulling back from optional meetings. Workload is still open to negotiation. Support: our own framework, plus one case in which withdrawal followed a dispute.
  2. Concerns put in writing. The specific problem can still be fixed if you close it in writing. Support: a consultant's experience, and the federal grievance rules for residents.
  3. Duties drifting to the ADON. You are now planning a transition. Support: our own framework. None of our sources measured this rung.

Before a resignation, burnout can hide behind good work and a confident self-assessment. After one, the loss turns up in star ratings and in a surveyor's three-year count. The stretch in between, when an administrator can still act, is the least studied, and what you can see there is behavior and paper. The evidence points first at keeping the DON you have. None of these sources shows the signals arriving in a fixed order, so treat any one of them as a reason to talk.

  • Ask your DON directly about hours and overtime, even when her results look fine.
  • Before your next survey, count your DONs and administrators over the last three years and set that list beside your citation history for the same period.
  • When your DON raises a concern, write down the answer you agreed and a date to close it.
  • Check that your resident grievance program includes the written decision step the federal rule requires.
  • If a dispute ends and your DON goes quiet, ask yourself whether the quiet means the problem is resolved or that she has pulled back.

How we checked this

We read two peer-reviewed studies (2021 and 2025), a December 2025 podcast interview with a long-term care compliance consultant, the federal resident rights rule (retrieved November 16, 2026), and a 2011 employee post on a legal question site. None of the figures in this section are ours. The burnout study covered nursing home managers in general and did not track resignations. The ratings study reports associations and cannot show cause. The 2011 case is one person's side of a dispute, written by someone who reported to a DON. Blyer sells compliance consulting services, which gives her a professional stake in how facilities think about survey risk. The three-rung ladder is our framework and has not been tested. Still unknown: how far ahead of a resignation any of these signs appear, and whether acting on the first one keeps a DON in the job.

  1. Journal of Nursing Management, study of burnout among nursing home managers, November 2021.
  2. Peer-reviewed study, nursing home leadership turnover and star ratings, September 2025.
  3. Robin Blyer, RB Health Partners, on The Let's Get Comfy Podcast transcript, December 2025, at 22:34 and 28:22.
  4. Electronic Code of Federal Regulations, 42 CFR 483.10 resident rights, retrieved November 16, 2026.
  5. JustAnswer, employee question about a new DON, October 2011.

Should you start a DON search when the first warning sign shows up?

No. On the first sign, fix the workload. A free 15-minute intro call is for later, when a search truly makes sense and you agree to one.

Most administrators feel the pull in two directions at once. One instinct says protect the building and quietly line up a replacement. The other says talk to your DON before it is too late. The first sign is where those two instincts collide, and where most of the damage is done.

The first sign is small. Your DON stops showing up to things that were never required. Watch for these:

  • The voluntary family meeting they used to open now runs without them.
  • The corporate clinical call marked optional gets a "can't make it" every week.
  • The new-hire welcome, the Friday walk-through with you, the mentoring hour with a new charge nurse: all dropped.
  • Required meetings still happen. Morning stand-up, QAPI and the care plan schedule stay intact.

That last point matters. A DON on the first rung is still doing the job. They are cutting what they can cut to survive the week. Nothing on the floor has failed yet, and nothing has shown up at survey.

Here is the tension. If you read that withdrawal as disloyalty and start a search, your DON will feel it within days. Buildings talk. If you read it as fatigue and ask what to take off the plate, you are negotiating hours, coverage and decision rights. You are not yet negotiating pay against a competing offer.

Wait for a resignation letter and the conversation flips. Now you are matching a number from another building, and the workload that drove the letter is still there on Monday.

I would make the first move this week. Sit down with your DON and ask one question: "Which two things on your plate should not be yours?" Then take one of them off, in writing, within a week.

Before that conversation, it helps to know where you stand. Our DON flight-risk check takes about 2 minutes and scores whether your current DON is likely to leave. Like the rest of our tools, it is free to use, and you need no sign-up to see the result. It is built for the employer side only: the administrator, owner or regional leader making the DON or ADON decision, not a job seeker sizing up their own next move.

Some administrators also want a read on the wider market before the talk: what other operators are doing about leadership turnover and staffing pressure. That is useful context. It is not a script, and it should not replace the conversation with your own DON.

Who does this not fit? A turnaround building with a plan of correction open may need a different DON entirely. In that case, withdrawal may be a fit problem, not a workload problem.

For a stable building, the first rung is cheap to fix. The second rung costs more.

Which rung is your DON on right now?

Our DON flight-risk check takes about 2 minutes and scores whether your current DON is likely to leave, using signs you can see from your own office.

Peer-reviewed research links DON turnover consistently with lower star ratings. Know the rung before your next one-on-one.

What do the second and third warning signs look like, and what should you do?

Once grievances are written and duties drift to the ADON, you are planning a transition. In 2024, 36.6% of Texas nursing home DONs had held the role under a year.

That Texas DSHS figure covers one state. It is not a national number, and it does not say DONs leave within a year. It does say that in Texas, more than a third of DON chairs had a new person in them. Many of the DONs you are trying to keep are still learning your building.

The second rung: complaints go on paper

On the first rung, your DON goes quiet. On the second, your DON starts writing things down. Look for:

  • Emails to you or corporate about staffing, agency hours or CNA accountability, each one more formal than the last.
  • Concerns copied to HR or a regional nurse who was never copied before.
  • The same problem raised more than once, with no written answer from you.

Unanswered written escalation has a predictable end. A 2011 thread on JustAnswer shows the pattern from the other side of the DON's desk. A restorative care coordinator said they visited the DON's office "approximately eight times over six months" about CNA accountability and resident care, and documented every visit. The CEO met with the DON, and two months later nothing had improved. The coordinator then stopped raising issues and had, in their words, "just gone to work, done my job, and gone home."

Whoever was right in that dispute, the shape is what matters. Written complaint, no resolution, then silence. Silence after a paper trail is not peace. It is the next rung.

When your DON's memos stop, check whether the problems stopped. If they did not, answer every open item in writing this week, with a date and an owner.

The third rung: the quiet handoff to the ADON

The last sign is the easiest to miss because it looks like good leadership. Your ADON runs morning stand-up. Your ADON signs the schedule and takes the survey-prep call. Your DON writes out processes "so anyone can follow them." Each step on its own is healthy delegation. Together, they read like a DON preparing the building for an exit.

At this rung, ask two questions. Can you still change the outcome? And is your ADON ready if you cannot?

For the second question, we built our Promote or hire? quiz. It takes about 2 minutes and tests whether an internal candidate is ready for the DON seat. We built it to recommend internal promotion whenever the answers support it, instead of always concluding that you should hire from outside.

If pay comes up in a last conversation, use numbers you can defend. Our pay data and DON pay benchmark are built from public sources cited on the page: BLS wage data, CMS facility and staffing data, and industry surveys. Treat any figure as guidance and check pay changes with your own HR or counsel before you put them in writing.

By this rung, a matching offer leaves the workload that drove the exit untouched. The cheaper fix was two rungs down, which is why it pays to know exactly which rung you are on.

How can I tell if my nursing home's Director of Nursing is a flight risk?

Watch behavior, not mood: skipped optional meetings, complaints in writing, then duties drifting to the ADON. Our DON flight-risk check scores those signs in about 2 minutes.

Leadership churn is becoming something surveyors ask about. Robin Blyer of RB Health Partners said on The Let's Get Comfy Podcast that she expects CMS to ask how many administrators and DONs a building has had in the last three years, then read three years of citations for a link to leadership change. Her answer to whether it matters: "of course the answer is yes."

So the question will get asked. Better you ask it first.

I would put the first rung on your calendar this week. Pull your DON's recent meeting attendance. If the answer later points to a transition, our Promote or hire? quiz tests whether your ADON is ready before you look outside, and the next step depends on what it finds.

Summarize This Article With AI

Open this article in your preferred AI engine for an instant summary.

Frequently Asked Questions

What else do administrators ask about DON flight risk?

Most questions come down to timing, cost and paper. Act on the first rung, keep written grievances moving to resolution, and treat a DON's quiet handoff as a transition already underway.

If staff keep complaining about the DON, is the DON the problem?

Not necessarily. A 2011 thread on JustAnswer shows how unresolved escalations play out. A restorative care coordinator documented every visit to the DON's office, the CEO then met with the DON, and two months later nothing had improved. After that, the coordinator stopped raising issues and had "just gone to work, done my job, and gone home." I read that as a building problem. When complaints go nowhere, people go quiet, and your DON can go quiet the same way.

Do grievances matter at survey?

Yes. A grievance is a written complaint the building has to log and resolve, and grievances fall under F-tag 585. A missing written grievance resolution is exactly the kind of gap a surveyor finds. Pull your grievance log this week and check that each entry has a written outcome.

Does DON turnover show up in my star rating?

Research links it there. DON turnover is consistently associated with lower star ratings and lower consumer satisfaction. That is an association from statistical models, not proof that one exit caused one lost star.

Can I just ask my DON whether they plan to leave?

You can. Ask about workload instead of loyalty. People who are never asked tend to find another way to say it, and in a nursing building that usually means a resignation letter.

What does hiring help from Director of Nursing Search cost?

Hiring help starts with a free 15-minute intro. If a search makes sense and you agree, we introduce a specialist recruiting firm that fits the role, state and timeline. The site is free, and it earns a referral fee when it introduces an employer to a specialist recruiting firm; the disclosure page explains how that works. Employers never pay us, and candidates never pay anything. You can book the intro here.

Written by

Dorian Hammer

Editor, Director of Nursing Search

Dorian Hammer edits the guides at Director of Nursing Search, written for administrators and owners of skilled nursing facilities and assisted living communities who need to hire or keep a Director of Nursing or ADON.

View profile