How a DON Departure Hits Your Five-Star Staffing Rating

A departing DON counts in RN and total nurse turnover, not administrator turnover. Contract RN hours can restore your staffing hours, but the turnover hit stays until the departure ages out.

Quick Answer

A departing DON counts in RN and total nurse turnover, not administrator turnover. Contract RN hours can restore your staffing hours, but the turnover hit stays until the departure ages out.

Turnover and the staffing star broadly move together. In CareListings' state ranking of CMS data as of March 24, 2023, the lowest-turnover state ran 39.7% turnover with a 4.36 average staffing rating. The state with the weakest rating averaged 1.56 stars at 59.7% turnover.

Did this answer your question?
Three things nursing home administrators believe. Myth or fact?
Call each one, then see how other readers called it.
1 When your DON resigns, the exit shows up in your administrator turnover count.
2 Care Compare scores weekend RN staffing apart from your weekday hours.
3 A low turnover figure on Care Compare proves your nursing leadership is stable.

After a Director of Nursing resigns, your owner will ask one question: what happens to the stars? The honest answer has two parts, and they run on different clocks. The staffing rating began with just two hours measures, RN hours and total staffing hours per resident day, according to CMS's Nursing Home Compare technical users' guide. The research section below walks through what the turnover side costs.

Most of the confusion comes from where CMS files the DON. Care Compare publishes administrator departures as their own count, so operators assume a leadership exit lands there. It does not. Which list your DON's exit lands on decides which recovery steps work and which only cost money, and the research section below shows where it lands.

The public record is thinner than most administrators expect. In its January 2022 announcement of the turnover data, CMS described its own work linking turnover to quality as early analysis rather than a settled finding. Our review of public sources this fall turned up DON tenure figures for a single state and no national DON or ADON turnover rate at all. So no benchmark will tell you whether your DON's exit was typical. What you can learn is the set of rules that decides how it scores.

I have laid this out in the order you will need it: where PBJ puts the DON, which staffing measures contract hours can rebuild, how far a departure travels through your other ratings, and how to spot the next resignation early. Begin with one item from your own records. Pull your last PBJ submission and check which job title your DON's hours were reported under.

When your Director of Nursing (DON) resigns, the first decision is which half of the staffing rating you are protecting. Contract RN hours are the tool most operators reach for first. The research section below walks through what they leave untouched. That split should shape every call you make over the next year, from the agency order you sign this week to how fast you fill the seat for good.

Most operators read a DON exit as a leadership problem. Care Compare sees it through staffing data your own building reports, as a 2022 CMS release on the enhanced rating system noted. A 2025 Ohio study of 789 facilities noted that CMS has no standalone DON turnover measure; the DON sits inside RN and total nursing staff turnover, "treated the same as all other staff," in the authors' words. The same 2025 analysis found that administrator turnover effects shrank once DON turnover was in the model.

The published turnover figures also miss churn. CMS's rule leaves short-stay hires out of the count, so I would not trust Care Compare to show a run of interim DONs.

This guide is for the administrator who has to explain a star drop to an owner. It works from public CMS and BLS data, the same sources behind our state-by-state DON salary benchmark, because BLS publishes no Director of Nursing occupation code of its own. Where the public data stops, I say so.

Questions this article answers

Where does CMS put your Director of Nursing in PBJ data?

CMS treats your Director of Nursing (DON) as an RN. A departure lands in RN turnover and total nurse turnover, not in administrator turnover, which CMS counts on its own.

Before the next Care Compare refresh, check three things in your own payroll records:

  1. Confirm your DON was reported in Payroll-Based Journal (PBJ) as an RN DON, not under an administrative category.
  2. Find the last date your former DON logged hours. CMS reads turnover from gaps in days worked, not from a termination date.
  3. List every RN with administrative duties who left in the same 12 months. They sit in the same RN turnover group as the DON.

The rules trace to CMS memo QSO-22-08-NH, dated Jan. 7, 2022. As the Center for Medicare Advocacy summarized it that month, Care Compare began posting three turnover measures over a 12-month period: the percent of RN staff who left, the percent of total nurse staff who left, and the number of administrators who left. Starting in July 2022, CMS used those measures in the Five-Star Quality Rating System. CMS's own Five-Star program page still points to that memo as the one that added staff turnover and weekend staffing measures to Care Compare.

Look at how the measures are expressed. Administrator turnover is a count of people. Nursing turnover is a percent. Your DON is in the percent.

The common assumption is that a DON is leadership, so CMS must file the exit next to the administrator's. It does not. CMS's turnover method lists the RN DON inside the RN group, alongside RNs with administrative duties and staff RNs. It lists the RN DON again inside total nurses, with LPNs, CNAs, aides in training and med aides. Nursing home administrators are tracked separately. Combining 3 sources points to one placement: in the staffing rating, your DON is counted as a nurse twice and as a leader nowhere.

In practice, one resignation moves two measures at once. If an RN with administrative duties also left during the same year, both exits sit in the same RN percent, and the smaller your RN roster, the more each one weighs.

The mechanics matter for timing. PBJ carries no termination dates. CMS infers a departure from gaps in days worked and employee system IDs, and an employee who returns after a gap of more than 60 days is treated, in effect, as a new employee. A DON who leaves, then comes back after a longer break, may register as a departure and a fresh hire.

I would start with the last date worked, because every later calculation hangs on it. Director of Nursing Search builds its pay data and DON salary benchmark from public sources cited on the page: BLS wage data, CMS facility and staffing data, and industry surveys. Reading CMS staffing data by job category rather than by job title is the habit the rest of this guide asks of you.

Your DON's exit now sits in two nurse percentages, and the next quarter's PBJ file decides how long the hours side stays short.

Can contract RN hours bring your staffing star back after a DON leaves?

Partly. Contract RN hours can rebuild the hours side of the staffing rating, but they cannot remove a DON departure from RN turnover, which already runs about 36.5% in skilled nursing.

That figure is the 2025 skilled nursing RN turnover estimate from HCS and AHCA. Your DON's exit lands on top of it.

Start with what helps. Hours worked by agency or contract RNs, LPNs and CNAs count in CMS's staffing data, and those hours feed the Five-Star rating. An interim or contract RN covering DON duties adds RN hours per resident day the same way an employed RN does. If the vacancy opened a hole in RN hours, coverage can close it in the next quarterly PBJ file.

Then what does not. CMS's Five-Star Technical Users' Guide explains that the staffing rating rests on six separate measures. Points are assigned for performance on each one, summed into a total staffing score, and compared against staffing rating point thresholds to set the star. Contract hours earn points only on the hours measures. The turnover measures keep scoring the departure. Contrary to the belief that a fully covered schedule protects the rating, a building sitting just above a threshold can lose a star on turnover points alone, with every RN shift filled.

Part of the staffing scoreWhat a DON exit doesCan contract RN hours repair it?
RN hours per resident dayRemoves the DON's RN hours until the seat is coveredYes, agency and contract RN hours count
Total nurse hours per resident dayRemoves the same hours from the nurse totalYes, under the same rule
Weekend nurse hoursCan thin out if weekend oversight slipsYes, if the cover is scheduled on weekends
RN turnoverAdds one departureNo
Total nurse turnoverAdds the same departureNo
Administrator turnoverNo changeNot affected

There is a twist in the other direction. A 2026 study of PBJ and Care Compare data by Petterson, Winter and colleagues found that CMS's turnover definition, which drops workers who log fewer than 120 hours in 90 days, excluded 45% of nursing hires by 2022 to 2023. The same researchers found that only 30% of facilities stayed in the same turnover decile once those short stints were counted, with the shifts concentrated in homes that used more contract staff.

Read that against your own vacancy. A short interim stint below that threshold may never enter the turnover count. The rating will not see that churn. Your floor nurses will.

So in rating terms, an open seat costs you hours points, while a covered seat costs you nothing on turnover that the departure has not already cost you. I follow changes to these definitions through our long-term care news feed on staffing and surveys, because any change to how CMS counts short stints would change how a DON vacancy scores.

The hours come back with the next file. The turnover stays until the departure ages out of the window, and that clock started on your DON's last worked day.

How far does one DON departure travel through your star ratings?

CMS names one leader in its turnover measures: the administrator. When researchers compared leadership departures with star ratings in Ohio, the exit more strongly linked to lower ratings belonged to a leader CMS never names.

Start with the arithmetic. CMS's technical users' guide builds the staffing rating from six measures: three count nurse hours per resident per day and three count turnover. Each earns points, and the total is compared with fixed thresholds to set the star. A departing DON reaches several measures at once, and only some respond to hours you buy.

An older CMS staffing FAQ states that agency and contract RN, LPN and CNA hours "are included in the Five-Star Rating System." The weekend measure is a special case. On an accounting firm's podcast about nursing home ratings, one speaker explained that it exists because the DON, unit managers and other administrative nurses usually work Monday through Friday.

Staffing measureDoes a DON exit land here?Can contract RN hours help?
RN hours per resident per dayYes, the DON's RN hours leave tooYes
Total nurse hours per resident per dayYesYes
Weekend nurse staffingOften little, if the DON worked weekdaysYes, if the hours fall on Saturdays and Sundays
RN turnoverYesNo
Total nurse turnoverYesNo
Administrator turnoverNo, CMS counts administrators who left as a separate numberDoes not apply

The two turnover rows run on their own clock. PBJ submissions carry no termination dates, so CMS infers each departure from gaps in days worked. A staffing guide from the workforce software vendor OnShift stresses that the calculation "is not based on employee termination dates." The resignation letter plays no part in the math. The last shift in your payroll data does.

How CMS's turnover clock works

  1. Each annual turnover figure draws on six consecutive quarters of PBJ data.
  2. Eligible staff are those who work at least 120 hours in a 90-day period that starts in the baseline quarter or the first two quarters.
  3. A departure is read from a gap in days worked.
  4. The result is reported as the share of staff who stopped working over a 12-month period.

Drawn from CMS's Five-Star technical users' guide and a January 2022 summary by CMS Compliance Group.

Who gets counted matters as much as when. The 120-hour rule screens out people who only cover the occasional shift. A 2026 study led by researchers at Virginia Commonwealth University found that by the 2022 to 2023 period, the rule excluded 45% of nursing hires. The CMS definition, the authors wrote, is built to emphasize "retention of established staff." A long-serving DON is exactly the established employee the measure is designed to catch. Recounting turnover to include every hire left only 30% of facilities in the same turnover decile, with the reshuffling concentrated in homes using more contract staff.

Contract cover adds its own wrinkle. CMS's guide notes that agency staff are included in the turnover measure alongside regular employees when they meet its conditions. An interim RN who covers the DON's desk for months could become one more counted employee in your turnover figures.

A wider cost may fall outside the staffing star entirely. Jenny Kwon, a health policy researcher at the University of California, San Francisco, worked with three colleagues to match 2017 Ohio data on leadership turnover with CMS star ratings for 789 nursing homes. Administrator turnover was tied to lower overall and health inspection stars, but those effects shrank once the researchers accounted for DON turnover.

2.9 to 11.5 percentage points

How much lower overall, health inspection and quality-measure star ratings ran where the DON had turned over, in Ohio nursing homes in 2017. Consumer satisfaction scores ran 0.4 to 1.5 points lower.

Within CMS's turnover measures, the authors note, DONs are "treated the same as all other staff," and they recommend a standalone DON measure. Their study covers one state in one pre-pandemic year, before turnover counted in the staffing star, and its cross-sectional design shows association rather than cause. Practitioners point the same way. On the accounting podcast, a speaker observed that higher-rated facilities consistently pair a closely involved administrator with a DON working right beside them.

Followed all the way through, one resignation splits into separate costs that run on separate clocks. Contract hours can replace the lost hours, and the quarterly PBJ data will show the change. The turnover entry stays for its full window no matter what you spend. And the Ohio evidence suggests that inspection and quality stars move with leadership stability, which no agency invoice supplies.

  • Find the DON's last worked day in your PBJ submission, because CMS reads that gap in days worked and has no use for the resignation date.
  • If the DON might come back, ask how the 60-day gap rule would treat the return, since a late comeback counts as a fresh hire.
  • Before you buy weekend shifts, check whether your weekend measure actually moved. If your DON worked weekdays, it may not have.
  • Ask your PBJ lead whether interim or agency cover will pass 120 hours in a 90-day period, and whether that person's eventual exit would then show up in turnover.
  • Track your health inspection and quality-measure stars through the vacancy, along with staffing.

How we checked this

We read CMS's Five-Star technical users' guides and an older CMS staffing FAQ. We also read summaries from a compliance consultancy and an advocacy group, two peer-reviewed studies, a guide from a workforce software vendor and one industry podcast. None of the figures here come from our own data. The Ohio study covers one state in 2017, before turnover counted in the staffing star, and it can show association rather than cause. The podcast reflects what its speakers have seen in practice. The CMS FAQ is undated and out of date on turnover, so we used it only to show that contract hours count. We earn a referral fee when we introduce employers to recruiting firms, as our disclosure page explains, so we have a stake in arguments that DON stability matters. Still unknown: how many rating points one exit costs a given facility, which depends on staff size and CMS's thresholds, and whether the Ohio pattern holds nationally today.

  1. CMS, Five-Star technical users' guide, undated, retrieved November 2026.
  2. HHS, Five-Star technical users' guide, July 2023 edition, published on hhs.gov.
  3. CMS Compliance Group, summary of the January 2022 guide update, January 22, 2022.
  4. Center for Medicare Advocacy, explainer on turnover and weekend staffing data, January 13, 2022.
  5. CMS, older staffing FAQ on contract hours, undated.
  6. OnShift (workforce software vendor), 2022 Five-Star staffing guide, undated.
  7. Kwon, Bowblis, Brunt and Xu, study of Ohio DON and administrator turnover, Journal of the American Medical Directors Association, September 11, 2025.
  8. Petterson, Winter and colleagues, study of CMS turnover definitions, April 18, 2026.
  9. Casey Peterson LTD, podcast episode on nursing homes and staffing models, May 1, 2023.

How can I tell if my nursing home's Director of Nursing is a flight risk?

No public dataset will warn you in time. Our October 2026 review of public sources found no national DON turnover rate, so the signs must come from your own building.

The one tenure figure we did find covers a single state. 36.6% of Texas nursing home DONs had held the role under a year, according to the Texas Department of State Health Services in 2024. It is a Texas number, not a national one, and it measures tenure, not exits. We found no published national figure for ADON turnover either.

Ask your DON this month what would make them leave, and what would make them stay. Writing in the Journal of the American Medical Directors Association in 2025, Kwon, Bowblis, Brunt and Xu found that DON turnover was associated with star ratings lower by 2.9 to 11.5 percentage points, and that the effect of administrator turnover shrank once DON turnover was in the model. Their data came from Ohio nursing homes in 2017, before turnover entered the staffing rating, and the design shows association, not cause. The research section above walks through what that turnover has been tied to. A second DON exit inside the same window counts again.

The fit drivers I watch are the ones that decide a hire in the first place: survey history, staffing, the ADON and the administrator. A DON with no ADON, an open plan of correction and a habit of working the floor to fill call-offs is a DON whose seat is at risk.

Once a DON gives notice, this is the order I would work in:

  1. Cover the RN hours first, with an acting ADON, an interim DON or contract RN shifts, so the next PBJ quarter does not show the hole.
  2. Settle the ADON question before you post the job. An ADON who wanted the seat and hears nothing may leave, and that exit lands in the same RN count.
  3. Write down what the next DON must fix in the first 90 days: open survey tags, the weekend schedule, agency hours. Hire against that list, not a title.
  4. Ask each finalist to walk you through a survey they led from citation to revisit.
  5. Recheck fit at day 90 with the same questions you used to hire.

There is a real trade-off here. Speed protects the hours side; patience protects the turnover side. I would rather carry a few more weeks of interim cover than hire someone who leaves inside the year and drops a second departure into the same count.

Director of Nursing Search built its free tools around these steps: a DON interview kit, a DON job-ad builder, a promote-or-hire quiz, a DON flight-risk quiz, a survey-readiness check and a hire-and-retain pay plan. Treat the pay plan as general guidance and check it with your own HR counsel before you use it.

Run the flight-risk quiz on your current ADON too. That is the seat that empties next if the promotion goes to someone else.

Need help filling your DON seat before the turnover window catches up?

Director of Nursing Search offers a free 15-minute intro. Our pay benchmark uses public BLS and CMS data only, because BLS has no Director of Nursing occupation code.

Kwon and colleagues tied DON turnover to lower star ratings. CMS added turnover to Care Compare, yet its rule leaves many short-stay hires out of the count. Contract hours cover the schedule. Only a hire who stays clears the window.

If a search makes sense and you agree, we introduce a specialist recruiting firm that fits the role, state and timeline. Employers never pay us; the site earns a referral fee from the firm. How Director of Nursing Search makes money.

Book a free 15-minute intro

What should you do this quarter if your DON just left?

Order the RN hours you need to hold the hours measures, then put your energy into a DON who stays, because only time clears a departure from turnover.

Conventional wisdom treats a DON exit as a one-quarter problem you can staff around. The rating does not work that way. CMS defines staff turnover as "the percent of nursing staff and number of administrators that stopped working at the nursing home over a 12-month period," as a 2022 Mandelbaum Barrett PC summary of the change put it. CMS builds those measures from staffing data your building reports itself, as its 2022 release on the enhanced rating system noted, so check that your PBJ submission codes the DON's hours and any interim RN hours correctly before the quarter closes. The research section above walks through why.

The same 2022 summary cited a Health Affairs study that put nursing staff turnover at 94 percent in 2017 and 2018. In a building with that kind of churn, the DON is the person who keeps new nurses on the same policies. CMS made a related point in its memo: facilities with lower nurse turnover may have staff better able to "identify a resident's change in condition sooner."

My first question would be whether your ADON is ready: the Director of Nursing Search promote-or-hire quiz says so when promoting from within is the honest answer, and referral fees never change what it recommends. Start with your own PBJ submissions. Mark the DON's last day and count forward to when it leaves the window. Our tools and pay data are free, with no sign-up, and employers never pay us. Then take that date into your next interview and ask the candidate what they would change in the first 90 days.

Summarize This Article With AI

Open this article in your preferred AI engine for an instant summary.

Frequently Asked Questions

What else do administrators ask about DON turnover and the staffing rating?

Most questions come down to timing: a DON exit stays in your RN and total nurse turnover for a full measurement window, and agency hours cannot shorten it.

How long does a DON departure stay in my turnover measure?

About a year. In its January 2022 release, CMS defined staff turnover as departures over a 12-month period. The exit drops out only when that window moves past the DON's last day.

Is CMS sure that lower turnover means better care?

Not fully. CMS called its own analysis of the turnover and quality link "preliminary" in that same 2022 release. I still treat it as a real risk, because the rating counts it either way.

How high is nursing turnover in skilled nursing overall?

High enough that one DON exit rarely lands alone. Average nursing staff turnover was 53.9% a year across 12,656 SNFs in CMS data as of March 24, 2023. Facilities with no reported turnover data were left out of that average.

Will a short interim DON show up in my turnover?

Often not. CMS's rule excludes workers below an hours threshold, so a brief interim can come and go without touching the measure. Your own staff will still feel the change.

Does the administrator count cover my DON?

No. Administrator turnover is a separate count of departures. Your DON is counted as a nurse.

What does Director of Nursing Search charge?

Nothing to employers. Hiring help starts with a free 15-minute intro call. If a search makes sense and you agree, we introduce a specialist recruiting firm that fits the role, state and timeline, and the site earns a referral fee from that firm, as our disclosure page explains. You can book the call from the DON search page.

Written by

Dorian Hammer

Editor, Director of Nursing Search

Dorian Hammer edits the guides at Director of Nursing Search, written for administrators and owners of skilled nursing facilities and assisted living communities who need to hire or keep a Director of Nursing or ADON.

View profile